Politics

Lawmakers are cramming controversial copyright provisions into a must-pass spending bill

Congress might finally pass the CASE Act, to the chagrin of Big Tech and civil liberties groups.

Lawmakers are cramming controversial copyright provisions into a must-pass spending bill

The CASE ACT, Trademark Modernization Act and a felony streaming proposal could make it into the year-end omnibus bill.

Photo: Getty Images

Lawmakers are cramming multiple controversial copyright provisions into a must-pass spending bill at the eleventh hour, stirring up pushback from tech companies and civil liberties activists who say they're skirting proper procedure in order to create a system that's vulnerable to abuse.

The House and Senate Judiciary Committees have agreed to include a package of three provisions — the controversial CASE Act, the Trademark Modernization Act and a felony streaming proposal — in the omnibus spending bill, which must pass before a Dec. 11 government shutdown deadline, according to two congressional aides.

A group of 18 organizations, including tech trade groups, advocacy organizations and multiple library associations, are urging congressional leadership to decline to include the provisions, according to a letter obtained by Protocol on Friday.

"We respect Congress's intent to improve our intellectual property system and protect the rights of creators and entrepreneurs," the groups, including the Internet Association, the Electronic Frontier Foundation and American Library Association, wrote. "However, certain aspects of this package of bills will have negative impacts on small- and medium-sized businesses, creators, libraries and their patrons, students, teachers, educational institutions, religious institutions, fan communities, internet users, and free expression."

Congress is still hashing out the contours of the spending bill, and they're running against a tough deadline as they negotiate over broader questions, including whether the bill should include COVID-19 relief spending.

But it's the closest Congress has come to actually passing the CASE Act, legislation at the center of a battle between Big Tech and rights holders. Supporters, including the Copyright Alliance, say the legislation would make it easier for independent artists to bring claims without going through federal court. Under the current system, victims of copyright violation have no cost-effective way to get compensated for their work when it's used without their permission. The CASE Act would create a quasi-judicial body in the Copyright Office to award damages up to $30,000 to copyright holders who find their creative work being passed around online.

But critics of the bill insist the CASE Act would just set up an easier system for copyright trolls to exploit without any ability to appeal. The Electronic Frontier Foundation has warned that the legislation could "ruin the lives of regular people; people who are engaging in the things we all do when we're online: sharing memes, sharing videos, and downloading images."

"Passing the CASE Act without reforms will unleash a host of lawsuits against innocent internet users and restrict their ability to defend themselves against trolls," said Democratic Senator Ron Wyden in a statement to protocol. Wyden previously tried to negotiate with Senators John Kennedy and Dick Durbin to figure out a different path forward on the CASE Act. "It is tremendously disappointing that powerful lobbying groups may be close to attaching this flawed legislation to a must-pass spending bill without commonsense changes to protect Americans from predatory copyright trolls."

The Trademark Modernization Act, meanwhile, would crack down on the increase in fraudulent trademark filings from foreign countries including China. It would give the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office more flexibility to crack down on illegitimate trademark claims — while also creating a new opportunity for so-called "trademark trolls" who make money off of registering trademarks without intending to use them. That legislation hasn't passed the House or the Senate.

And the final provision, Republican Sen. Thom Tillis' felony streaming proposal, has not yet been introduced as legislation. But the proposal would provide the DOJ with the authority to charge commercial enterprises that are streaming certain kinds of works with felony copyright infringement, a primary concern for professional sports organizations and the powerful Motion Picture Association.

The three provisions are likely being tied together in order to create a coalition of rights-holders against the proposals' many critics, said one tech industry source.

"All signatories have serious concerns with at least some aspect of the bills slated to be included in their current state, and we stand ready to work with Congress to avoid their unintended consequences," the letter reads.

The House Judiciary Committee and Senate Judiciary Committee did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

"This backroom deal to empower copyright and trademark trolls as part of a must-pass bill would have sweeping negative consequences for the entire internet ecosystem," said Mike Lemon, a senior director with the Internet Association, which represents the Silicon Valley giants. "Copyright and trademark reform are important policy issues that warrant fulsome, measured debate. Jamming such significant measures into a government funding bill is bad policymaking."

Entertainment

Roku execs: The death of the dongle has been greatly exaggerated

Smart TVs are becoming more important, but Roku plans to sell dongles for years to come.

Roku CEO Anthony Wood said streaming adapters are “not going away anytime soon.”

Photo: Roku

Roku isn’t ready to give up on dongles: Company executives told reporters and analysts this week that streaming adapters remain a key part of the company’s business, despite reports of consumers increasingly migrating to smart TVs for their binge-watching needs.

“Every year I've been here, someone has called the demise of the streaming player,” Roku CFO Steve Louden told Protocol following the company’s earnings release Thursday afternoon. “It continues to be a good source of accounts for us.”

Keep Reading Show less
Janko Roettgers

Janko Roettgers (@jank0) is a senior reporter at Protocol, reporting on the shifting power dynamics between tech, media, and entertainment, including the impact of new technologies. Previously, Janko was Variety's first-ever technology writer in San Francisco, where he covered big tech and emerging technologies. He has reported for Gigaom, Frankfurter Rundschau, Berliner Zeitung, and ORF, among others. He has written three books on consumer cord-cutting and online music and co-edited an anthology on internet subcultures. He lives with his family in Oakland.

Sponsored Content

How Intel Partner University helps build core cloud competency

In a fast-moving world, keeping abreast of developments has never been more important.

The world of cloud computing has become ever more complicated as the world relies increasingly on the underlying technology that powers our key apps, services and products. Data drives our world, and will continue to define our future. Edge computing, the proliferation of 5G and the rise of AI and big data all require cloud computing at a scale never seen before.

That has created a need and an opportunity for IT professionals to learn about new, advanced technologies. “Cloudification is driving critical demand for a broad range of cloud skills, including DevOps, Migration Execution, Data Planning, Cloud Security and CSP optimization,” said Rob Rollinger, Director of Intel® Cloud.U at Intel. Gaining a specialization in these areas offers the opportunity for experts to promote their work, build a career and gain new experiences that may lead to new job opportunities.

Keep Reading Show less
Chris Stokel-Walker

Chris Stokel-Walker is a freelance technology and culture journalist and author of "YouTubers: How YouTube Shook Up TV and Created a New Generation of Stars." His work has been published in The New York Times, The Guardian and Wired.

Entertainment

Play Sifu, watch ‘Inventing Anna’ and more weekend recs

Don't know what to do this weekend? We've got you covered.

Image: Netflix; Sloclap; Mnz/Unsplash

This week we’re addicted to Sifu, one of the best Chinese martial arts action games released in a while. Grifter stories are sweeping Netflix, with “Tinder Swindler” and “Inventing Anna” both keeping us on our toes. And are you ready for the vibe shift?

Keep Reading Show less
Nick Statt
Nick Statt is Protocol's video game reporter. Prior to joining Protocol, he was news editor at The Verge covering the gaming industry, mobile apps and antitrust out of San Francisco, in addition to managing coverage of Silicon Valley tech giants and startups. He now resides in Rochester, New York, home of the garbage plate and, completely coincidentally, the World Video Game Hall of Fame. He can be reached at nstatt@protocol.com.
Workplace

How to get Black employees to stay, despite The Great Resignation

Black workers are burning out. Here’s how you can keep them from quitting.

The Great Resignation has shown us how widely distributed “burnout” is — and how narrowly distributed opportunity is for so many American workers.

Photo: GaudiLab via Getty Images

La Toya Haynes is the director of Racial Equity at Intuit.

Call it the Great Resignation, call it the “I-quit” movement, call it post-pandemic burnout — whatever we label it, employees are leaving their jobs. In November 2021 alone, 4.5 million workers quit.

Keep Reading Show less
La Toya Haynes
La Toya Haynes is the director of Racial Equity at Intuit, the global technology platform powering TurboTax, QuickBooks, Mint, Credit Karma and Mailchimp. She holds a Bachelor’s degree in business management from Southern University and A&M College and a Master’s degree in organizational development and executive coaching from the University of Texas.
Enterprise

What VCs miss about SaaS revenue

Protocol caught up with Lightspeed Venture Partners’ Nnamdi Iregbulem to talk about revenue concentration in SaaS and why today’s metrics don’t give investors the full picture.

Nnamdi Iregbulem, a partner at Lightspeed Ventures, spends his spare time writing about his theories on data and investing.

Photo: Lightspeed Venture Partners

Nnamdi Iregbulem is a tech nerd at heart. A self-taught programmer who started building computers as a teenager, his interests in mathematics, economics and statistics eventually took him from investment banking at JPMorgan to Stanford’s graduate school. Now, he’s a partner at Lightspeed Venture Partners.

When not investing in enterprise software like GitLab, Alteryx and SurveyMonkey, Iregbulem spends his time writing about his theories on data and investing. In one of those essays, Iregbulem outlined a new metric he created called weighted average contract value (WACV), which he argues provides more meaningful information about SaaS revenues than the traditional average contract value (ACV). In the SaaS industry, where it’s common for a small number of customers to account for the majority of a startup’s revenue, calculating an average doesn’t properly account for the influence of large customers. WACV can tell a startup where most of the revenue is coming from, which customers are most important and where the most risk is.

Keep Reading Show less
Aisha Counts

Aisha Counts (@aishacounts) is a reporter at Protocol covering enterprise software. Formerly, she was a management consultant for EY. She's based in Los Angeles and can be reached at acounts@protocol.com.

Latest Stories
Bulletins