Apple Epic Trial

App Store chief argues the virtues of Apple's walled garden

Matt Fischer took the stand in the fourth day of testimony in Epic v. Apple.

App Store chief argues the virtues of Apple's walled garden

Matt Fischer is the current App Store vice president and reports directly to longtime executive Phil Schiller.

Photo: David Paul Morris/Getty Images

Apple isn't expected to start building its official defense in the antitrust fight with Epic Games until the week after next, but one of its key executives at the heart of the dispute began laying the groundwork in court on Thursday.


Matt Fischer, the current App Store vice president who reports directly to longtime executive Phil Schiller, took the stand in Oakland as an Epic witness to answer questions about the App Store business model, as well as its role in the broader iOS operating system. Fischer is arguably the most high-profile Apple employee on the witness list outside Schiller and other members of Apple's executive leadership, and his testimony provides part of the foundation for the company's justification of its App Store commission.

So far, Apple counsel has revealed its strategies through opening arguments and at times aggressive cross-examination of Epic witnesses, including CEO Tim Sweeney and a number of third-party game industry executives. That's involved comparing iOS and the App Store to the console game ecosystems of Microsoft, Sony and Nintendo, and suggesting that game makers are just fine reaching iOS customers through cloud streaming and mobile web browsers if they don't like Apple's policies.

But Fischer provided the company's first robust rationalization for many of the App Store's more controversial policies. He called the store "incredibly unique" in the benefits it provides to consumers and developers and steadfastly defended it against claims that Apple overlooks fraud. That, in turn, justifies the commission Apple collects and the restrictions it imposes.

"We work really hard to make the App Store a marketplace that's attractive to both customers as well as to developers," Fischer testified. "I might be biased, but I certainly l think that what we do is incredibly unique, and I certainly have not seen any marketplace that distributes apps or games do what we're doing in terms of providing marketing and editorial support like this to developers."

The key takeaway from day four is that the future of this trial could very well hinge on how Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers perceives the true purpose of the App Store. Is it a level playing field designed to protect user privacy and security and take only its fair share? Or is it an increasingly byzantine pillar of Apple's walled garden, one preoccupied with chasing profit and marred by inconsistently applied and ever-changing rules? Fischer, and Apple by extension, would very much like it to be seen as the former. Epic, of course, the latter.

Central to this characterization will be how Apple justifies keeping out competing game-streaming and subscription apps, like Microsoft's Xbox Game Pass and Google Stadia. That was the focus of a rather grueling cross-examination of Epic witness and Xbox Vice President Lori Wright on Wednesday. Another factor will be whether Fischer and others at Apple can successfully downplay or dismiss concerns of special treatment, like the deals Apple has cut with Amazon in the past to reduce its commissions for streaming video apps.

Fischer did his part in that regard, when he was asked outright by Apple lawyer Jay Srinivasan whether any developer receives special treatment. "The App Store review guidelines apply equally to all developers," Fischer replied. He also commented on the notion that Apple privileges its own apps over those of competitors, saying, "We have promoted apps that are competitive to Apple apps since before I joined the App Store team in 2010, and we continue to not only distribute but to feature and promote apps that are competitive to Apple apps in the store. We do this all the time."

Epic lawyer Katherine Forrest spent much of her time questioning Fischer by trying to poke holes in Apple's security justification, which the company has used to deny alternative payment processing systems that could, as Epic's did, bypass the App Store's fees. Forrest listed more than a dozen companies that use their own payment processing systems, companies like PayPal-owned Braintree and Amazon, that are allowed to do so because they process transactions of non-digital goods, of which Apple does not take a 30% cut.

Fischer said he could not recall any study Apple conducted on the security or privacy of any third-party payment system relative to Apple's. Later, during cross-examination, Fischer asserted he is in fact not responsible for security, privacy, fraud or app review.

Fischer confirmed to Epic that Apple has in the past given certain developers exclusive access to APIs and other privileges, after use of the term "whitelisted" was shown in emails related to Hulu's use of a not-yet-released API for canceling and refunding consumer subscriptions. During cross examination, Fischer disputed the term whitelisting, going so far as to call it "offensive," and later claimed access to such features was part of an ongoing testing process conducted through its TestFlight program.

"In this particular case, it was something we were testing with a few companies to see how this feature would perform, with the intention that, if it performed well, we would roll it out to all developers," Fischer argued.

Fischer, as the first Apple employee to be cross-examined by Apple counsel, used his time in front of Srinivasan to promote the App Store as a fair marketplace that goes above and beyond what other app stores do to support developers. Fischer described his early relationship with Epic, during the years the developer made the Infinity Blade trilogy of iOS games, and later when Fischer worked with Epic to promote a holiday Fortnite skin in the winter of 2018. He said Apple gave Epic valuable onstage time during its developer conferences to promote the games.

"Did Epic pay Apple for any of that support?" Fischer was asked. "No, they did not," he said. Fischer also said Apple was willing to change its rules at Epic's request, including when it began allowing in-app gifting for Fortnite, a feature Fischer said it enabled for all developers. "When we make a change, we want to make a change that applies equally to all developers," Fischer said.

The App Store chief also shed light on how Apple came to the conclusion it would not charge certain app makers a 30% fee if they produced a physical good or service, compared to a digital one like Epic and other game developers.

"The decision was made that for an app that sells physical goods and services, it didn't make sense for Apple to earn a commission as part of that, because we ultimately didn't know if that good or service would be delivered to the end user," he said, using the example of an Uber ride or an Amazon package ordered through an iPhone. Apple does not take a cut of those purchases and allows those developers to use their own payment systems.

Epic has taken issue with this distinction, saying it unfairly penalizes competing software distributors while exempting companies that make use of much of the same Apple technology and platform benefits. But Fischer cast the decision as another reason Apple keeps tight control over its ecosystem, because it's concerned primarily with whether users are receiving what they paid for when they buy something that is primarily experienced on the iPhone itself, such as an in-game purchase in Fortnite.

"[Apple in-app payment] in its simplest form is a way to sell digital content within an app. But actually it's a lot more complicated than that," Fischer argued, saying it "enables the safe and frictionless delivery of digital goods from a developer to a user."

That argument — that the App Store's control over digital purchases is for the good of the platform and not a profit ploy — will likely be one Apple and its lawyers fall back on as the trial moves forward.

Workplace

Ask a tech worker: How many of your colleagues have caught omicron?

Millions of workers called in sick in recent weeks. How is tech handling it?

A record number of Americans called in sick with COVID-19 in recent weeks. Even with high vaccination rates, tech companies aren’t immune.

Illustration: Christopher T. Fong/Protocol

Welcome back to Ask a Tech Worker! For this recurring feature, I’ve been roaming downtown San Francisco at lunchtime to ask tech employees about how the workplace is changing. This week, I caught up with tech workers about what their companies are doing to avoid omicron outbreaks, and whether many of their colleagues had been out sick lately. Got an idea for a future topic? Email me.

Omicron stops for no one, it seems. Between Dec. 29 and Jan. 10, 8.8 million Americans missed work to either recover from COVID-19 or care for someone who was recovering, according to the Census Bureau. That number crushed the previous record of 6.6 million from last January, and tripled the numbers from early last month.

Keep Reading Show less
Allison Levitsky
Allison Levitsky is a reporter at Protocol covering workplace issues in tech. She previously covered big tech companies and the tech workforce for the Silicon Valley Business Journal. Allison grew up in the Bay Area and graduated from UC Berkeley.

COVID-19 accelerated what many CEOs and CTOs have struggled to do for the past decade: It forced organizations to be agile and adjust quickly to change. For all the talk about digital transformation over the past decade, when push came to shove, many organizations realized they had made far less progress than they thought.

Now with the genie of rapid change out of the bottle, we will never go back to accepting slow and steady progress from our organizations. To survive and thrive in times of disruption, you need to build a resilient, adaptable business with systems and processes that will keep you nimble for years to come. An essential part of business agility is responding to change by quickly developing new applications and adapting old ones. IT faces an unprecedented demand for new applications. According to IDC, by 2023, more than 500 million digital applications and services will be developed and deployed — the same number of apps that were developed in the last 40 years.[1]

Keep Reading Show less
Denise Broady, CMO, Appian
Denise oversees the Marketing and Communications organization where she is responsible for accelerating the marketing strategy and brand recognition across the globe. Denise has over 24+ years of experience as a change agent scaling businesses from startups, turnarounds and complex software companies. Prior to Appian, Denise worked at SAP, WorkForce Software, TopTier and Clarkston Group. She is also a two-time published author of “GRC for Dummies” and “Driven to Perform.” Denise holds a double degree in marketing and production and operations from Virginia Tech.

The fast-growing paychecks of Big Tech’s biggest names

Tech giants had a huge pandemic, and their execs are getting paid.

TIm Cook received $82 million in stock awards on top of his $3 million salary as Apple's CEO.

Photo: Mario Tama/Getty Images

Tech leaders are making more than ever.

As tech giants thrive amid the pandemic, companies like Meta, Alphabet and Microsoft have continued to pay their leaders accordingly: Big Tech CEO pay is higher than ever. In the coming months, we’ll begin seeing a lot of companies release their executive compensation from the past year as fiscal 2022 begins.

Keep Reading Show less
Nat Rubio-Licht
Nat Rubio-Licht is a Los Angeles-based news writer at Protocol. They graduated from Syracuse University with a degree in newspaper and online journalism in May 2020. Prior to joining the team, they worked at the Los Angeles Business Journal as a technology and aerospace reporter.
Boost 2

Can Matt Mullenweg save the internet?

He's turning Automattic into a different kind of tech giant. But can he take on the trillion-dollar walled gardens and give the internet back to the people?

Matt Mullenweg, CEO of Automattic and founder of WordPress, poses for Protocol at his home in Houston, Texas.
Photo: Arturo Olmos for Protocol

In the early days of the pandemic, Matt Mullenweg didn't move to a compound in Hawaii, bug out to a bunker in New Zealand or head to Miami and start shilling for crypto. No, in the early days of the pandemic, Mullenweg bought an RV. He drove it all over the country, bouncing between Houston and San Francisco and Jackson Hole with plenty of stops in national parks. In between, he started doing some tinkering.

The tinkering is a part-time gig: Most of Mullenweg’s time is spent as CEO of Automattic, one of the web’s largest platforms. It’s best known as the company that runs WordPress.com, the hosted version of the blogging platform that powers about 43% of the websites on the internet. Since WordPress is open-source software, no company technically owns it, but Automattic provides tools and services and oversees most of the WordPress-powered internet. It’s also the owner of the booming ecommerce platform WooCommerce, Day One, the analytics tool Parse.ly and the podcast app Pocket Casts. Oh, and Tumblr. And Simplenote. And many others. That makes Mullenweg one of the most powerful CEOs in tech, and one of the most important voices in the debate over the future of the internet.

Keep Reading Show less
David Pierce

David Pierce ( @pierce) is Protocol's editorial director. Prior to joining Protocol, he was a columnist at The Wall Street Journal, a senior writer with Wired, and deputy editor at The Verge. He owns all the phones.

Hybrid work has some distinct advantages when it comes to onboarding.

Photo: LogMeIn

Jo Deal is the chief human resources officer at LogMeIn. She is responsible for leading global people strategy with a focus on attracting, developing and engaging talent.

The desire for change that sprung up during the pandemic resulted in the highest attrition levels in decades and a fierce war for talent playing out in the market. The Great Resignation forced managers to suddenly make hiring their top priority, and recruitment partners became everyone’s best friend as leaders scrambled to replace key roles within their teams.

Keep Reading Show less
Jo Deal
Jo Deal serves as LogMeIn’s Chief Human Resources Officer. She is responsible for leading global people strategy with a focus on attracting, developing and engaging world class talent by expanding LogMeIn’s reputation as one of tech’s most desirable career destinations, and by providing a collaborative learning environment where employees can grow their careers.
Entertainment

Peloton’s terrible, horrible, no good, very bad year

2022 just started, and Peloton has already halted bike production and is talking about mass layoffs. How did the pandemic darling get here?

How did Peloton go from pandemic star to sinking ship? One answer is the classic problem of supply and demand.

Image: Peloton; Protocol

It’s been a hell of a ride for Peloton. The headlines have been practically nonstop, from 2019’s cringey wife ad to 2021’s series of unfortunate “Sex and The City” events. But in 2020, Peloton could do no wrong. The at-home fitness company saw a 172% spike in sales over the course of that year, buoyed by the pandemic forcing wealthy gym-goers to stay home.

But nothing is ever easy or certain when it comes to Peloton. In the past week, Business Insider reported that Peloton is considering laying off 41% of its sales and marketing staff and closing down stores. CNBC learned that the company has hired McKinsey & Co. to help cut costs. And yesterday, CNBC reported that Peloton is temporarily halting production of its bikes. Peloton shares promptly plunged 24%.

Keep Reading Show less
Lizzy Lawrence

Lizzy Lawrence ( @LizzyLaw_) is a reporter at Protocol, covering tools and productivity in the workplace. She's a recent graduate of the University of Michigan, where she studied sociology and international studies. She served as editor in chief of The Michigan Daily, her school's independent newspaper. She's based in D.C., and can be reached at llawrence@protocol.com.

Latest Stories
Bulletins