Bulletins

Last-minute scramble as China firewalls Clubhouse

Last-minute scramble as China firewalls Clubhouse
That didn't last long. Less than a week after Clubhouse exploded in the Chinese-speaking world — at least those with a VPN and access to the Apple app store — Clubhouse is banned in China. Chinese users reported Monday evening Asia time that it was blocked. As usual, the Chinese government did not issue an announcement or explain its reasoning; news simply spread that the app had become inaccessible.

Clubhouse had provided the first real opportunity in over a decade for Chinese-speaking populations — including mainland Chinese, Hong Kongers, Taiwanese and the larger Chinese diaspora — to communicate with each other, uncensored, in one place. Facebook and Twitter were censored in China in 2009, following deadly riots in Xinjiang in Western China.

What's happening:

  • People from "inside" the Chinese state system, or with families in state law enforcement were on it, too. Not only were they lurking, they were speakers, too. One user on Monday night just said that they believed Clubhouse wouldn't be banned in China overnight because China was becoming more confident in its governance. Ironically, Clubhouse became inaccessible in China a few hours after that assessment was made.
  • Many mainland Chinese users are still on Clubhouse, for now. They continued to access Clubhouse via VPNs Monday night after the block.
  • Users are hurriedly exchanging alternative contact info while they can. They are worried that it soon might become harder for them to access Clubhouse. Some have changed their profile images to QR codes to various Clubhouse friend groups on WeChat. Some have listed their Weibo and Douban handles in bios.
  • It was a rare, remarkable moment. Candid conversations occurred in multiple chat rooms on Clubhouse over the past week between Han Chinese, Uyghurs, Taiwanese, Hong Kongers and the overseas diaspora. On Sunday, more than 4,500 people tuned in to a Mandarin chat room discussing massive human rights abuse in Xinjiang. The conversations went on for hours and moved many listeners. Politics was just one topic discussed on the platform. Users were talking just about everything — art, life, work, gossip. Artist Ai Weiwei called the week of expression bursts a carnival.

How users are reacting:

    • Many fear repercussions for their use of Clubhouse. The fear is not unfounded. One troll said they took screenshots and claimed that they had recorded many of the conversations and had a transcript. Many Chinese users have expressed unease about Agora, the technology provider behind Clubhouse and a NASDAQ-listed Chinese tech company with operations in both China and the U.S. Users say they fear that the Chinese government could collect user bios and acoustic fingerprints through Agora. One Agora co-founder, Tony Wang, has told the South China Morning Post that the company doesn't store user data.
    • Some are still hopeful. The rare, unfiltered Mandarin conversations that occurred on Clubhouse gave slim hope to many Chinese Clubhouse users who felt their voices had long been suppressed. Some are still hopeful and wish to keep the conversations going. One Chinese user told Protocol the past few days restored their optimism and faith in social media. Rayhan E. Asat, a Uyghur lawyer who lives in the U.S. and who says her brother, Ekpar Asat, is in an internment camp in Xinjiang, said it was heartening to see the solidarity between Han people, Uyghurs and other Turkic people. "I hope people can find ways to continue these discussions so that together we can close these brutal concentration camps," she told Protocol. "I don't believe Han people wish to be citizens of a country that commits genocide but a country that celebrates diversity."
    • "It was worthwhile." Zuola, a dissident blogger in Taiwan who moderated a marathon chat room that facilitated conversations between mainlanders, Taiwanese and Hong Kongers, said the fact that people from different backgrounds were able to speak in an orderly manner and share their thoughts proves that "democracy is a good thing." "By asking participants to just share ideas, not to refute others' views, I was able to create a sense of a moderate and rational community," he told Protocol. "Many people were touched to have such an environment to speak and listen, which made me feel that the 130 hours of non-stop live streaming was worthwhile."
    Latest Bulletins

    Expensify, which makes cloud software that helps businesses manage their expenses, filed for an initial public offering on Friday.

    Keep Reading Show less

    Netflix fired the person who organized the upcoming walkout over Dave Chappelle's new comedy special, "The Closer," on suspicion of disclosing metrics to the press, according to The Verge. The worker, who is Black, was not named for fear of online harassment.

    Keep Reading Show less

    This week Google began rolling out an infinite scroll feature "for most English searches on mobile in the U.S.," according to the company. Prior to the update, mobile users had to click a button to load a new page of results.

    Keep Reading Show less

    The director of the U.S. Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency tweeted Friday in praise of people "working to find and responsibly disclose vulnerabilities."

    Keep Reading Show less

    Beijing is considering elevating the Antimonopoly Bureau to a vice-ministerial level agency amid a widening regulatory crackdown on Big Tech, Reuters reported Wednesday.

    Keep Reading Show less

    A top Google executive on Friday criticized a major forthcoming antitrust bill in the Senate, warning that the American Innovation and Choice Online Act could have "unintended consequences" that break "a range of popular products that people use everyday."

    Keep Reading Show less

    The Securities and Exchange Commission is expected to approve the first bitcoin futures ETF next week.

    Keep Reading Show less

    A prominent human rights activist and Saudi dissident is suing Twitter for allegedly hiring two men who acted as spies for the Saudi government. The suit accuses Twitter of negligence in its failure to detect the two spies inside the company — who are currently under indictment from U.S. federal prosecutors — and prevent them from stealing personal information for the Saudi government.

    Keep Reading Show less

    Atlassian will reopen most of its U.S. offices next month, the company told employees Wednesday.

    Keep Reading Show less

    Coinbase wants Congress to prevent the Securities and Exchange Commission from regulating crypto and turn the job over to a new body, according to a new report.

    Keep Reading Show less

    LinkedIn founder and early Facebook investor Reid Hoffman applauded Facebook whistleblower Frances Haugen for coming forward and said he is "disappointed" in how the company handled the problems she disclosed to begin with. "It's OK to have done the internal research and not reported it," he said in an interview with Bloomberg. "But you then start the work streams to fix it."

    Keep Reading Show less

    Netflix CEO Ted Sarandos wrote an all-staff memo Wednesday night that once again defended the company's decision to stream Dave Chapelle's new comedy special, "The Closer," which has drawn widespread criticism from LGBTQ-plus activist groups.

    Keep Reading Show less

    HTC unveiled its new Vive Flow consumer headset Thursday morning, positioning it as a device for meditation, downtime and mental well-being. The headset is priced $499, and can be preordered starting Thursday; it will begin shipping in November.

    Keep Reading Show less

    Microsoft will remove its platform for LinkedIn in China later this year because of the difficult internet compliance rules set by the Chinese government, according to a Thursday announcement.

    Keep Reading Show less

    Top House Democrats unveiled a bill Thursday that would force big online companies like Facebook and Twitter to face liability if the algorithms that shape their sites push content that drives harm in the real world.

    Keep Reading Show less

    Americans overwhelmingly believe that social media makes it easier to spread misinformation and fake news, a new survey found, but they're divided along stark partisan lines when it comes to how heavily they weigh that concern against other issues, like censorship.

    Keep Reading Show less

    Reddit has launched a new feature that will allow users to predict the outcomes of real-world events and place virtual "tokens" as bets on the likelihood of their predictions.

    Keep Reading Show less

    A bipartisan group of senators will introduce a bill prohibiting Big Tech platforms from giving preference to their own offerings, according to a release from Sen. Amy Klobuchar, the Democrat leading the group.

    Keep Reading Show less

    WeChat and Tencent's other popular messaging app QQ has blocked searches of Coinbase, along with names of other crypto exchanges, Protocol has learned.

    Keep Reading Show less

    Microsoft has hired a law firm to conduct an independent review of the human rights and surveillance impacts of its contracts with law enforcement, including federal immigration agencies and the New York Police Department, following pressure from activist shareholder group Open Mic.

    Keep Reading Show less

    Amazon engaged in "a formal, clandestine strategy" of copying other sellers' goods with its own brands in India and then ensured its offerings appeared near the top of searches on the ecommerce platform, according to a Reuters investigation.

    Keep Reading Show less

    Snapchat went down for some users Wednesday morning. The platform tweeted around 7:45 a.m. ET that it was looking into the issue and tweeted again around 10:30 a.m. ET that the problem had been resolved.

    Keep Reading Show less

    Stripe is building a crypto team, three years after the fintech powerhouse shut down support for bitcoin.

    Keep Reading Show less