Bulletins

Clubhouse is blowing up in China

Clubhouse logo overlayed with the Chinese character for "fire."
David Wertime

Chinese users are suddenly flooding in to the group audio chat app Clubhouse. Here's what you need to know.

  • Who's on Clubhouse? China's elites. More specifically: Tech workers, social media opinion leaders, dissidents, activists and journalists both in China and outside of China.
  • Clubhouse is on the Weibo trending chart. One day after Elon Musk appeared on Clubhouse, the hashtag "Clubhouse Invite Code" appeared as a trending topic on the Chinese social media platform.
  • What are users talking about? One big topic: Politics. As censorship becomes increasingly pervasive on Chinese social media, Mandarin speakers are using Clubhouse as a new public square for political discourse. Late Tuesday night, Asia time, users in mainland China, Hong Kong and Taiwan stayed up late to debate Chinese identity and democracy. Things got heated when it came to Hong Kong protests, China's handling of the pandemic and censorship.
  • Invite codes are for sale. Clubhouse has become so popular in China that those with invitations are now selling it on Xianyu, China's second-hand marketplace app. Although sellers appear to outnumber buyers, and you need an Apple account outside of China to get in.
  • Tech insiders are already talking about copying it. PMs are wondering aloud who will copy it first. Wu Yunfei, a member of the product team behind Dizhua (递爪), an app similar to Clubhouse, wrote that he entered a Clubhouse room with hundreds of Chinese product managers and had "mixed feelings" hearing people talking about how to copy it to China. Justin Sun, a Chinese entrepreneur who founded crypto platform TRON, quickly announced on Twitter that he was building a similar app named "Two" to replicate Clubhouse's success in China.
  • Realtime audio chat rooms are nothing new in China. There are already similar audio-based social networking apps in China, but none of them has gone mainstream. Clubhouse reminds many Chinese internet users of YY, an online chatroom-turned major live-streaming platform. While YY used to be a popular communications tool among gamers (think Discord) or between influencers and their fans, it was never considered an elite platform. Chinese cab and truck drivers also have their own live group chats on WeChat. But urban elites only got into live chats after Elon did.
Shen Lu

Shen Lu is a reporter with Protocol | China. Her writing has appeared in Foreign Policy, The New York Times and POLITICO, among other publications. She can be reached at shenlu@protocol.com.

and
 Zeyi Yang
Zeyi Yang is a reporter with Protocol | China. Previously, he worked as a reporting fellow for the digital magazine Rest of World, covering the intersection of technology and culture in China and neighboring countries. He has also contributed to the South China Morning Post, Nikkei Asia, Columbia Journalism Review, among other publications. In his spare time, Zeyi co-founded a Mandarin podcast that tells LGBTQ stories in China. He has been playing Pokemon for 14 years and has a weird favorite pick.
Latest Bulletins

Activision Blizzard asks the court to halt California's discrimination suit

Activision Blizzard is asking a California court to halt the state's ongoing discrimination lawsuit over alleged ethical violations first raised by the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), which has begun engaging in a series of back-and-forth disputes with California's Department of Fair Employment and Housing (DFEH).

Keep Reading Show less

Twitter's head of trust and safety is leaving after a 13-year run

Twitter's vice president of trust and safety Del Harvey announced Tuesday that she is leaving the company this week after nearly 13 years. Her last day is Friday.

Keep Reading Show less

Alibaba unveils new custom server chips

Chinese tech giant Alibaba unveiled a new in-house designed server chip based on technology licensed from Arm, which will be manufactured with the advanced 5-nanometer process, the company said early Tuesday.

Keep Reading Show less

Facebook to pay $14 million for alleged bias against US workers

Facebook will pay up to $14.25 million to settle allegations it "routinely refused to recruit, consider or hire U.S. workers" for certain positions, the U.S. Justice Department announced on Tuesday.

Keep Reading Show less

Google's Pixel Pass is a new subscription bundle to rival Apple One

Google is launching a new subscription service designed to both sell its new Pixel 6 smartphone and promote its bevy of existing paid software services. It's called the Pixel Pass, and it bundles a new Google handset with YouTube Premium, YouTube Music Premium, Google Play Pass and Google One cloud storage.

Keep Reading Show less

The public wants Congress to crack down on Facebook

Nearly 70% of Americans believe there should be stricter content standards on Facebook, including rules that would prevent misinformation and hate speech from proliferating on the platform. The findings come from to a new poll conducted by Morning Consult.

Keep Reading Show less

Sundar Pichai calls for Geneva Conventions on cyberwarfare

Google CEO Sundar Pichai is calling on the U.S. government to create an equivalent to the Geneva Conventions for cyberwarfare, in the wake of increasing attacks from Russia, China and other countries targeting the U.S. and its allies. Pichai made the statement during an interview with the Wall Street Journal at the publication's WSJ Tech Live conference on Monday.

Keep Reading Show less

Facebook is now testing its Novi digital wallet in the US

Facebook's Novi digital wallet is now available in most U.S. states and Guatemala in a pilot test of the product, the company said Tuesday. Users can access the platform as a mobile app available on both Apple's App Store and Google Play.

Keep Reading Show less

Invesco drops plans for Bitcoin ETF before ProShares debut

Invesco won't be launching a futures-backed Bitcoin exchange-traded fund after all, the ETF operator said Monday. Invesco pulled out just one day ahead of asset manager ProShares' debut of the first-ever Bitcoin futures ETF on Tuesday.

Keep Reading Show less

SEC: GameStop trading frenzy ‘tested the capacity of our markets’

The Securities and Exchange Commission said the January GameStop trading frenzy "tested the capacity and resiliency of our securities market in a way that few could have anticipated," as the agency released its much awaited report on the incident.

Keep Reading Show less

Apple takes down several religious apps in China

A website that tracks Apple's App Store globally has reported a recent slate of takedowns of Quran and Bible-related apps in China.

Keep Reading Show less

Facebook fights back against the media by criticizing … embargoes?

Facebook has made a series of increasingly aggressive statements in recent weeks, attempting to undermine The Wall Street Journal's reporting on thousands of pages of leaked internal documents. On Monday, the company tried a new approach, chastising reporters for such indiscretions as … collaborating and agreeing to press embargoes.

Keep Reading Show less

Netflix trans employees have a list of demands for Wednesday's walkout

The Netflix trans employee resource group released a list of demands to the company ahead of a planned Wednesday walkout over the controversial Dave Chappelle special "The Closer," asking for increased investment in trans-affirming content and recruitment of trans leaders, adding disclaimers and labels for transphobic content and other changes.

Keep Reading Show less

NY attorney general is investigating crypto lending platforms

New York Attorney General Letitia James is investigating crypto lending platforms, calling them "high-risk virtual currency schemes."

Keep Reading Show less

Facebook wants to hire 10,000 people to build the metaverse

Facebook wants to be the company that moves our lives into the shared virtual reality known as the metaverse — and apparently, the company needs to hire 10,000 engineers in the European Union to make that happen.

Keep Reading Show less

Amazon wants to hire 150,000 workers in the middle of a labor shortage

Amazon would like to hire 150,000 seasonal workers across more than 20 states, in addition to more than 100,000 non-seasonal workers in warehousing and delivery — all while the country faces a notoriously stubborn labor shortage that's leaving even popular employers with a hard time filling jobs.

Keep Reading Show less

Lawmakers say Bezos and others at Amazon may have lied to Congress

Top Amazon officials, including former CEO Jeff Bezos, appear to have misled Congress regarding the company's treatment of third-party sellers, according to a bipartisan group of lawmakers.

Keep Reading Show less

Comcast launches XClass smart TV manufactured by Hisense

Comcast has launched its first smart TVs in the U.S.: The company officially announced the launch of two TV models manufactured by Hisense under the XClass TV brand Tuesday. Executives painted the launch as part of an ambitious expansion beyond the company's core cable footprint.

Keep Reading Show less

Expensify has filed to go public

Expensify, which makes cloud software that helps businesses manage their expenses, filed for an initial public offering on Friday.

Keep Reading Show less

Netflix fires the employee who was leading the Dave Chappelle walkout

Netflix fired the person who organized the upcoming walkout over Dave Chappelle's new comedy special, "The Closer," on suspicion of disclosing metrics to the press, according to The Verge. The worker, who is Black, was not named for fear of online harassment.

Keep Reading Show less

Google rolls out infinite scrolling on mobile search results

This week Google began rolling out an infinite scroll feature "for most English searches on mobile in the U.S.," according to the company. Prior to the update, mobile users had to click a button to load a new page of results.

Keep Reading Show less

CISA head reminds public that vulnerability reporting is actually good

The director of the U.S. Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency tweeted Friday in praise of people "working to find and responsibly disclose vulnerabilities."

Keep Reading Show less

China’s antitrust watchdog gets more power

Beijing is considering elevating the Antimonopoly Bureau to a vice-ministerial level agency amid a widening regulatory crackdown on Big Tech, Reuters reported Wednesday.

Keep Reading Show less