Bulletins

FTC sues Meta to prevent it from acquiring VR fitness app Supernatural

Meta was reportedly willing to spend as much as $500 million for Supernatural.

Supernatural

The FTC is trying to stop Meta's acquisition of Supernatural.

Image: Supernatural

The Federal Trade Commission has filed a lawsuit against Meta and Within, the startup behind the VR fitness app Supernatural. The agency is asking a federal court for a preliminary injunction to stop the two companies from proceeding with an acquisition, alleging the deal would limit competition.


Meta announced its plans to acquire Within in October. The startup's VR fitness app Supernatural has been a surprise hit, and Mark Zuckerberg has called fitness a key part of his company's strategy to broaden the appeal of VR beyond hardcore gaming.

Through a series of key acquisitions and pricing strategies, Meta has turned its VR business into the market's most dominant platform, with a 90% market share in hardware, according to IDC, and subsidiaries behind some of the most successful VR apps, like best-selling rhythm video game Beat Saber. Acquiring yet more software makers could further cement that dominance, critics and regulators have contended.

The FTC alleges this acquisition would be harmful to consumers and competitors alike. “Instead of competing on the merits, Meta is trying to buy its way to the top,” said FTC Bureau of Competition Deputy Director John Newman in a statement. “Meta chose to buy market position instead of earning it on the merits. This is an illegal acquisition, and we will pursue all appropriate relief.” Meta would be able to close the acquisition of Within by the end of this month if no preliminary injunction is granted, according to the filing.

A Meta spokesperson called those arguments "not credible." "The FTC's case is based on ideology and speculation, not evidence," the spokesperson said in a statement provided to Protocol. "By attacking this deal in a 3-2 vote, the FTC is sending a chilling message to anyone who wishes to innovate in VR. We are confident that our acquisition of Within will be good for people, developers and the VR space.”

The agency further expanded on its position in the complaint itself. "If consummated, the acquisition would substantially lessen competition, or tend to create a monopoly, in the relevant market for VR dedicated fitness apps and the broader relevant market for VR fitness apps," the complaint states. "That lessening of rivalry may yield multiple harmful outcomes, including less innovation, lower quality, higher prices, less incentive to attract and keep employees, and less consumer choice."

The preliminary injunction is meant to give the FTC time to issue an administrative complaint against the merger, and then start full-blown administrative proceedings. Taking that step against a startup acquisition is part of the FTC's more aggressive stance against Big Tech, which includes a focus on emerging technologies.

FTC Chair Lina Khan told Protocol last month that AR and VR were especially important markets for the agency. "I think these types of nascent, expanding markets are definitely on our radar and top of mind," Khan told Protocol. "Especially in as much as VR or AR [are] also becoming a major part of how some of these games are functioning for users and [how] users are interacting."

Latest Bulletins

Some of the most popular reproductive health apps lack strong privacy labels and security practices, according to a report published by Mozilla Wednesday.

Keep Reading Show less

Microsoft has finally broken its silence on a sales figure secret its kept close to its chest for more than half a decade.

Keep Reading Show less

The U.S. Commerce Department has implemented an export control on advanced chip design software that’s necessary to produce next-generation processors, expanding on existing controls that target chipmaking tools with the goal of hampering Chinese efforts to build the most complex chips domestically.

Keep Reading Show less

What was supposed to be a blockbuster crypto merger has morphed into a legal brawl. Galaxy Digital said Monday that it has terminated its $1.2 billion bid to buy BitGo, which it accused of failing to produce “audited financial statements."

Keep Reading Show less

Andreessen Horowitz is betting big on Adam Neumann's return to the real estate startup game.

Keep Reading Show less

Unity rejected AppLovin's offer to buy the company in an all-stock deal valued at $20 billion and instead will move forward with a plan to buy ad tech and monetization software company ironSource, the company said Monday.

Keep Reading Show less

Marqeta shares fell about 25% Thursday after the company revealed a weak outlook and founder Jason Gardner said he would step down.

Keep Reading Show less

Atlantic states may have a head start in the offshore wind game, but California has a plan to catch up — and even surpass — them.

Keep Reading Show less

The Federal Trade Commission has officially begun the long-awaited process of regulating digital data by reining in "surveillance" and lax security in a move that could have sweeping consequences for Big Tech and industries far beyond.

Keep Reading Show less

Meta announced it is expanding end-to-end encryption in Messenger, just days after news broke that the company gave Nebraska law enforcement Messenger chats between a 17-year-old girl and her mother discussing a medical abortion. Meta told Wired the announcement and the Nebraska case are unrelated, however, Meta would not have been able to access the chats if the girl and mother had used end-to-end encryption.

Keep Reading Show less

Coinbase said the SEC is looking into different aspects of the crypto company’s business, including “existing and intended future products,” according to a regulatory filing.

Keep Reading Show less

Microsoft accused its gaming rival Sony of trying to hurt the success of its subscription gaming platform by signing contracts with game developers that prohibit distribution through Xbox Game Pass, according to a new regulatory filing published in Brazil. The news was first reported by gaming outlet VGC on Wednesday.

Keep Reading Show less

Disney is getting ready to introduce an ad-supported Disney+ plan in December and will use that occasion to significantly raise the price of its existing ad-free subscription tier.

Keep Reading Show less

The CFPB said Wednesday that it has imposed a $2.7 million fine on Hello Digit, an app that claims to help users put aside money for rainy days but that the regulator said messed up their finances.

Keep Reading Show less

Facebook gave law enforcement in Nebraska private messages sent between a mother and a 17-year-old girl, who are now facing several charges in the state relating to a medication abortion the girl had. Facebook was served a search warrant, which was obtained by Vice, asking for their private data as part of the state's investigation.

Keep Reading Show less

Video game software company Unity can get bought by AppLovin or merge with ironSource, but it can’t do both.

Keep Reading Show less

Coinbase posted dismal results Tuesday as the crypto powerhouse got slammed by a downturn that “came fast and furious.”

Keep Reading Show less

Over the weekend, the Senate passed the Inflation Reduction Act. The legislation is the largest investment in addressing climate change ever made at the federal level.

Keep Reading Show less

The U.S. has begun cracking down on imported goods from China that may have been made with Uyghur forced labor. That includes solar panels, which have been detained at the border or shipped back to China in recent weeks.

Keep Reading Show less

As pressure mounts on Big Tech to do more to protect the youngest users, Snap is launching a new family center that will allow parents to see who their kids are friends with on Snap and report suspicious accounts.

It’s part of a wave of new kid safety features being launched by tech giants, including Meta and Apple. But Snap has an arguably bigger hill to climb in implementing these features than either of those companies. To get parents of teens to use Snap’s parental controls, first, parents of teens need to actually use Snap.

Keep Reading Show less

North Korean hackers used Tornado Cash, a mixer platform for cryptocurrencies, to launder funds. That's according to the U.S. Treasury Department, which imposed sanctions on the USDC and ETH wallet addresses associated with the protocol Monday.

Keep Reading Show less

Google has filed a new patent infringement lawsuit against Sonos, alleging the violation of four patents. Most of the claims focus on voice assistant functionality; Google alleges that Sonos began violating its patents when Sonos introduced its own voice assistant this summer.

Keep Reading Show less

Twilio disclosed that a cyberattack involving the theft of employee credentials allowed attackers to access data from "a limited number" of customer accounts.

Keep Reading Show less

Block reported second-quarter earnings that just topped analysts’ estimates, but shares fell as investors digested the effect of the macroeconomic environment on the company’s core payments businesses. Bitcoin volume also dragged on total revenue.

Keep Reading Show less

Meta announced Thursday it had banned Cyber Front Z, a pro-Russia troll group that purported to mobilize harassment by supporters of Vladimir Putin's war in Ukraine through a public Telegram channel.

Keep Reading Show less
Bulletins