Bulletins

Why Twitter banned Trump

It's clear from Dorsey's tweets that he loathed having to take the action.

Jack Dorsey
Photo: Amal KS/Hindustan Times via Getty Images

Jack Dorsey, after a notably long silence on his platform's ban of @realdonaldtrump, took to Twitter on Wednesday night to try and explain himself. (Maybe he's finally home from his vacation in French Polynesia.)


"I do not celebrate or feel pride in our having to ban @realDonaldTrump from Twitter, or how we got here," Dorsey wrote. "After a clear warning we'd take this action, we made a decision with the best information we had based on threats to physical safety both on and off Twitter." Over a series of tweets, he tried to explain, but the answer seemed to boil down to the fact that the possibility of real-world harm seemed large and imminent, and Twitter felt it had to act.

It's clear from Dorsey's tweets that he loathed having to take the action, even if he believed it to be the right one. "Having to take these actions fragment the public conversation," he said. "They divide us. They limit the potential for clarification, redemption, and learning. And sets a precedent I feel is dangerous: the power an individual or corporation has over a part of the global public conversation." This, by the way, is a power and a precedent a lot of people feel is dangerous. Dorsey has proven to be one of the internet's — one of society's — most powerful people, and he doesn't seem to relish that responsibility.

More problematic for Dorsey is the fact that cloud providers like AWS also took actions on objectionable content last week. Dorsey said that the fact that users could always leave Twitter for another service was core to its ability to moderate as it saw fit; with fewer places to go, Dorsey seemed to say, Twitter's role might feel different.

Lastly, Dorsey used the opportunity to cast a broader vision for Twitter, the same one he's been talking about for a while now: Twitter as a protocol, not a platform. The project is called BlueSky, and it's already in progress at Twitter. It attempts to discover what it might look like if the internet had a conversational layer, and apps could plug into it however they wanted? Twitter would turn into something more like an email client: one way to view the underlying content, but not the only way, and certainly not the controller of the ecosystem.

That idea, he said, is part of why he's so fascinated by Bitcoin, "because of the model it demonstrates: a foundational internet technology that is not controlled or influenced by any single individual or entity. This is what the internet wants to be, and over time, more of it will be."

In short, it seems Dorsey feels Twitter made the right decision, wishes it didn't have to, and wants to build a world where it doesn't have to again. Or at the very least, one where Twitter can run the platform it wants to run without worrying about whether one CEO should be able to shut up the president.

Latest Bulletins

Twitter will begin taking action against misinformation in crisis situations, the company said Thursday, the new policy will be immediately applied to misinformation surrounding the war in Ukraine.

Keep Reading Show less

Cisco blamed COVID-19 lockdowns in China and the war in Ukraine for its flat revenue growth during the fiscal third quarter, and forecast for a declining current quarter when it reported earnings late Wednesday.

Supply shortages appear to be the largest culprit, and CEO Chuck Robbins said during a conference call Wednesday that the company’s disappointing revenue was the result of its inability to secure adequate components to sell its various products. The lockdowns in China were especially damaging, Robbins said.

Keep Reading Show less

Block just detailed plans for its self-custody bitcoin hardware wallet, aiming to bring together the often contradictory goals of convenience and crypto security. Block's goal is to monetize the wallet through a subscription service.

Keep Reading Show less

Apple's loss is Google's gain: Ian Goodfellow, who was a director in Apple's machine learning division, left the company recently, citing the company's return-to-office policy as the reason for his departure. Goodfellow is reportedly joining Google's DeepMind AI group.

Keep Reading Show less

SEC Chair Gary Gensler warned Congress Wednesday that consumers and investors are vulnerable in an increasingly volatile crypto market now reeling from a sharp downturn.

Citing the recent collapse in the crypto market's value, Gensler said, “This is a field that is now worth $1.2 trillion. Two weeks ago it was supposedly worth $2 trillion.”

Keep Reading Show less

New York Attorney General Letitia James is launching an investigation into social media companies' role in this past weekend's mass shooting in Buffalo, which the shooter mapped out on Discord for months prior to the attack and livestreamed on Twitch before the video was taken down.

Keep Reading Show less

Salesforce will slow hiring and cut back other expenses, according to a Wednesday report from Insider. The company will join Meta, Netflix, Coinbase, Uber and others that have slowed or frozen hiring in recent weeks.

Per an internal memo, cutbacks will include corporate travel and some upcoming off-sites, Insider reported.

Keep Reading Show less

Tesla's cars have helped spur an electric vehicle revolution. But that wasn't enough to stop the S&P 500 from removing the company from its ESG list on Tuesday, leading Elon Musk to call the list a "scam" that has been "weaponized by phony social justice warriors."

Keep Reading Show less

The Department of Homeland Security has paused work on its recently announced Disinformation Governance Board, according to The Washington Post. The board's director, Nina Jankowicz, has also resigned following an unrelenting stream of harassment. The Post first reported Jankowicz's resignation, and Protocol has since confirmed it.

The board's rollout was shoddy even by DHS Sec. Alejandro Mayorkas' own admission. From the outset, DHS revealed next to nothing about the board's goals or its authorities, leading to concerns that this new entity might be surveilling social media and deciding what does and doesn't constitute disinformation. Conservatives also quickly pounced on Jankowicz, accusing her of being a partisan hack. According to the Post, DHS forbid Jankowicz from saying anything publicly in her own defense.

In truth, the goal of the board, Mayorkas explained far too late, was to do the opposite of what it was being accused of. Throughout DHS, agencies are already working on ways to combat misinformation and disinformation. The purpose of the board was to coordinate those efforts and ensure that they weren't crossing lines with regard to free speech and privacy.

But the decision to do that in a public way rather than in a private audit drew undue scrutiny to the effort. As one source familiar with DHS' plans recently told Protocol, “Having a very large governance board and a really big, public rollout for it with a very well-known person in this space very publicly leading it, that probably drove their risk up a little more than it needed to."

In a statement, DHS spokesperson Angelo Fernandez said the board has been "grossly and intentionally mischaracterized," and confirmed that the Homeland Security Advisory Council is now leading a review of the board in hopes of answering two questions. "First, how can the Department most effectively and appropriately address disinformation that poses a threat to our country, while protecting free speech, civil rights, civil liberties, and privacy. Second, how can DHS achieve greater transparency across our disinformation-related work and increase trust with the public and other key stakeholders," Fernandez said.

The final recommendations are due within 75 days, during which time, the board's work will be paused.

Among the board's critics were not just the usual suspects in conservative circles, but also platform regulation scholars and legal experts who feared that the well had already been poisoned. Elon Musk and Jeff Bezos also got in on the act, with Bezos tweeting this week that the "newly created Disinformation Board should review" one of President Biden's tweets about taxing the wealthy to fix inflation.

This story has been updated to include comments from DHS.

The North Sea is already an offshore wind-power hotspot globally. The European Union is about to take further advantage of the bountiful breeze there in an effort to meet its climate goals and end its dependence on Russian oil and gas.

Keep Reading Show less

Failing to credit original creators will cost platforms users. TikTok has come under fire for this in the past, and it's now trying to keep original creators on the app with new attribution tools.

The platform announced it's rolling out the ability to directly tag, mention and credit a video in the description on Wednesday. TikTok is also adding more prompts to credit original users in the process of posting a video. Once a user creates or edits a TikTok video, they can tap on a tag page and select the content that uses the same sound. That tag will be added as a mention in the video's caption.

Keep Reading Show less

New York state's Division of Human Rights has filed a complaint against Amazon that claims that the company forces workers who are pregnant and workers with disabilities to take unpaid leave instead of making accommodations for them that would allow them to continue working.

Keep Reading Show less

Recent college graduates expect more out of their jobs — approximately $70,000, to be exact.

Recruiting software company iCIMS released its Class of 2022 Report on Wednesday. The latest edition of the annual report examines job trends, career expectations and aspirations of the most recent college grads entering the workforce. Researchers at the recruiting software company surveyed 500 HR and recruiting professionals and 1,000 recent college graduates to better understand their sentiments about workplace expectations.

Keep Reading Show less

Andreessen Horowitz is officially planting a flag in the game industry with the launch of its very first gaming fund.

The $600 million fund, which the firm is calling Games Fund One, will focus on a mix of game studios, gaming infrastructure companies and consumer gaming software providers — similar to Discord and Twitch, the firm says — that support gaming ecosystems and communities.

Keep Reading Show less

Michael Bloomberg is pouring nearly a quarter-billion dollars into supporting the clean energy transition abroad.

Keep Reading Show less

Netflix has laid off 150 employees as part of previously announced cost-cutting efforts. According to a report from Deadline, the layoffs are across departments, and primarily impact U.S.-based staff.

Keep Reading Show less

Top Twitter executives are fleeing the company in a sign that everything is fine (right?). Three senior employees are leaving the company in the midst of ongoing Elon Musk acquisition drama, according to Bloomberg.

Keep Reading Show less

Tiger Global sold off its stakes in some high-flying companies as tech stocks took a tumble at the beginning of the year — particularly some that recently went public. The firm, known for taking controversially big bets on late-stage startups paired with a hands-off approach, slashed its entire stake in Bumble, Airbnb, Affirm, PayPal and DiDi this year.

Keep Reading Show less

Elon Musk is slamming the brakes on his deal to acquire Twitter due to what he considers a huge issue on the platform: the actual number of spam accounts. But detecting bots is a lot harder than it looks.


Keep Reading Show less

Disney is opening up its flagship streaming service to advertising, but the company is being cautious: According to Variety, Disney+ won't allow alcohol-related or political ads to keep the service family-friendly.

Keep Reading Show less

Apple has once more delayed its plan to require employees to come to the office three days a week, although most workers were already required to return to the office twice a week. The company claimed that the rise in COVID-19 cases necessitated a pause in the controversial and much-protested ramp up, according to a Bloomberg report.

Keep Reading Show less

Last year was a banner year for renewable power in the U.S. But there’s no time to rest on our laurels: If the country wants to meet its climate and emissions reduction goals, more solar panels and wind turbines need to be installed at an even faster pace.

Keep Reading Show less

Now, it’s tether taking a hit. The world's largest stablecoin has seen investors pull out $7 billion amid the ongoing crypto crash.

The market circulation of tether, also known as USDT, has dropped from about $83 billion on May 11 to around $76 billion on Tuesday, according to CoinMarketCap. The decline coincided with the crash of another major stablecoin, UST, and its sister cryptocurrency luna.

Keep Reading Show less

Coinbase is reining in its hiring plans, according to a Monday blog post from president and COO Emilie Choi. Choi said she had shared the note with employees earlier, but wanted to announce the news publicly.

Keep Reading Show less

Twitter asked shareholders to vote on Elon Musk's takeover of the company at a special meeting. In short, Twitter wants to move forward with the purchase whether Musk likes it or not.

The company asked shareholders in a proxy statement to vote in favor of the acquisition, according to a filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission. The date for the special meeting has not yet been set.

Keep Reading Show less
Bulletins