China

Livestreaming ecommerce is the next battleground for China’s nationalists

Vendors for Nike and even Chinese brands were harassed for not donating enough to Henan.

Screenshots of nationalists trolling in livestream comments.

Nationalists were trolling in the comment sections of livestream sessions selling products by Li-Ning, Adidas and other brands.

Collage: Weibo, Bilibili

The No. 1 rule of sales: Don't praise your competitor's product. Rule No. 2: When you are put to a loyalty test by nationalist trolls, forget the first rule.

While China continues to respond to the catastrophic flooding that has killed 99 and displaced 1.4 million people in the central province of Henan, a large group of trolls was busy doing something else: harassing ordinary sportswear sellers on China's livestream ecommerce platforms. Why? Because they determined that the brands being sold had donated too little, or too late, to the people impacted by floods.

The result is something both comical and sad: Because of the countless comments swarming into livestream sessions of Nike and Adidas products to berate the brands, some on-camera staff for the sportswear companies felt necessary to stick pieces of paper to their bodies that said "We support Erke" — a competing Chinese brand that has been heralded for its 50 million RMB ($7.7 million) donation to charities working on the ground in Henan.

In today's China, nationalism finds a way to integrate itself into seemingly any technology innovation. Starting with the COVID-19 lockdown in 2020, livestreaming ecommerce has been one of the highlights of China's tech industry, growing into a trillion-RMB market. Its popularity also means it's vulnerable to populist attacks.

It all started with Erke, a faded, 21-year-old Chinese sportswear brand. On July 21, it executed a PR masterstroke, announcing on social media platform Weibo that it would donate millions in cash and goods to the disaster-stricken area. The brand went instantly viral. People commended Erke for donating an amount of money comparable to much more successful brands, even as the company itself is struggling financially.

The emergence of livestream ecommerce offers Erke a convenient way to convert that surge in popularity into real income. Overnight, millions of people participated in Erke's shopping livestream sessions on Taobao. The viewership of its regular livestream grew from the low thousands to over 19 million by July 24. There were so many purchases that the brand had to apologize for not having enough inventory to meet demand.

"Patriotism sells," Guobin Yang, a professor researching social movement and digital culture at the University of Pennsylvania, told Protocol. "It is a product of popular culture and commerce and is not unique to China. Think about the patriotism in Hollywood movies."

But the patriotic buying frenzy turned dark, quick. It soon became not just about supporting the brand that donated, but also about boycotting the brands that donated too little or too slowly.

Li-Ning, the second best-selling Chinese sportswear brand, became an early target. A day after Erke's announcement, Li-Ning posted on Weibo that it would donate $1.5 million in cash and $2.3 million worth of goods to charities working in Henan.

Social media was not satisfied. One of the Weibo comments, which received over 9,000 likes, reads: "You always advertise your patriotism but you must have gained a lot from raising prices during the time of the Xinjiang cotton [boycott]. When the country is in danger, you donate much less than brands like Anta and Erke."

The angry crowd then left Erke's livestreams and went to Li-Ning's, spamming the comment section with "Erke" or accusing Li-Ning of being a "Han traitor." Recorded videos of the livestream sessions, still available on platforms like Weibo and Douyin, show that some on-camera staff were harassed so thoroughly that they stopped talking and waited in silence for the stream to end.

There's also misinformation circulating around claiming Li-Ning is actually not a Chinese company. Like many Chinese companies, Li-Ning is incorporated in the Cayman Islands.

This is not the first time nationalism has resulted in mass-spamming on livestream ecommerce platforms. Back in March, during the boycott against foreign brands who said they would not use cotton produced in Xinjiang, fervent nationalist trolls — not to mention many ordinary web users — also attacked livestream vendors of Nike and Adidas products. Many of these vendors were just distributors, not Nike or Adidas employees, but that didn't make a difference.

The March boycott actually benefited Li-Ning, which at the time emphasized its Chinese ownership and attracted patriotic buyers. Now it has become the one being boycotted. Unsurprisingly, livestream channels of Adidas and Nike were also attacked (again) after the Henan flooding, even though the two companies have donated to the impacted people in Henan too.

Consumer boycotts are neither new or surprising, said Kacie Miura, assistant professor in political science and international relations at the University of San Diego. "But over the last decade or so, in part because of social media, boycotts of foreign brands that are perceived as having said or done something offensive to China seem to be occurring with greater frequency."

The latest development shows that not just foreign brands but also domestic brands and their employees can become victims of nationalist consumer boycotts. And as livestreaming becomes the dominant marketing tool, it has become a new cultural battleground.

Luckily, like anything on social media, patriotic boycotts disappear as quickly as they arrive. As of Thursday, the trolls have receded, and the ecommerce sellers have gone back to their busy schedule filled with hours of non-stop livestreaming. On social media, people have also started to reflect on, and even denounce, the harassment toward livestream sellers.

One of the only scars left in the visible digital world is in Li-Ning's livestream channels. The comment section, usually stuffed with viewer product questions, lies nearly empty. At the peak of attacks, Li-Ning disabled the commenting function to limit the scale of impact. It still hasn't opened it back up.

"I don't think the cyber-nationalists in the stories you shared are true believers," Yang said. "They may attack the Nike brand today, but will just as comfortably wear Nike shoes tomorrow. Their nationalism is part of their consumerism more than the other way around."

Maria Renz: Gopuff will make it through the fast-delivery slump

Maria Renz on her new role, the state of fast delivery and Gopuff’s goals for the coming year.

Gopuff has raised $4 billion at a $15 billion valuation.

Photo: Gopuff

The fast-delivery boom sent startups soaring during the pandemic, only for them to come crashing down in recent months. But Maria Renz said Gopuff is prepared to get through the slump.

“Gopuff is really well-positioned to weather through those challenges that we expect in the next year or so,” Renz told Protocol. “We're first party, we control elements of our mix, like price, very directly. And again, we have nine years of experience.”

Keep Reading Show less
Sarah Roach

Sarah (Sarahroach_) writes for Source Code at Protocol. She's a recent graduate of The George Washington University, where she studied journalism and criminal justice. She served for two years as editor-in-chief of GW's independent newspaper, The GW Hatchet. Sarah is based in New York, and can be reached at sroach@protocol.com

Some of the most astounding tech-enabled advances of the next decade, from cutting-edge medical research to urban traffic control and factory floor optimization, will be enabled by a device often smaller than a thumbnail: the memory chip.

While vast amounts of data are created, stored and processed every moment — by some estimates, 2.5 quintillion bytes daily — the insights in that code are unlocked by the memory chips that hold it and transfer it. “Memory will propel the next 10 years into the most transformative years in human history,” said Sanjay Mehrotra, president and CEO of Micron Technology.

Keep Reading Show less
James Daly
James Daly has a deep knowledge of creating brand voice identity, including understanding various audiences and targeting messaging accordingly. He enjoys commissioning, editing, writing, and business development, particularly in launching new ventures and building passionate audiences. Daly has led teams large and small to multiple awards and quantifiable success through a strategy built on teamwork, passion, fact-checking, intelligence, analytics, and audience growth while meeting budget goals and production deadlines in fast-paced environments. Daly is the Editorial Director of 2030 Media and a contributor at Wired.
Enterprise

AT&T CTO: Challenges of the cloud transition are interpersonal

Jeremy Legg sat down with Protocol to discuss the race to 5G, the challenges of the cloud transition and nabbing tech talent.

AT&T CTO Jeremy Legg spoke with Protocol about the company's cloud transition and more.

Photo: AT&T

Jeremy Legg is two months into his role as CTO of AT&T, and he has been tasked with a big mandate: transforming the company into a software-driven business, with 5G and fiber as core growth areas.

This isn’t Legg’s first CTO gig, just his biggest one. He’s an entertainment biz guy who’s now at the center of the much bigger, albeit less glamorous, telecom business. Prior to joining AT&T in 2020, Legg was the CTO of WarnerMedia, where he was the technical architect behind HBO Max.

Keep Reading Show less
Michelle Ma

Michelle Ma (@himichellema) is a reporter at Protocol, where she writes about management, leadership and workplace issues in tech. Previously, she was a news editor of live journalism and special coverage for The Wall Street Journal. Prior to that, she worked as a staff writer at Wirecutter. She can be reached at mma@protocol.com.

Workplace

How Canva uses Canva

Design tips and tricks from the ultimate Canva pros: Canva employees themselves.

Employees use Canva to build the internal weekly “Canvazine,” product vision decks, team swag and more.

Illustration: Christopher T. Fong/Protocol

Ever wondered how the companies behind your favorite tech use their own products? We’ve told you how Spotify uses Spotify, How Slack uses Slack and how Meta uses its workplace tools. We talked to Canva employees about the creative ways they use the design tool.

The thing about Canva is that it's ridiculously easy to use. Anyone, regardless of skill level, can open up the app and produce a visually appealing presentation, infographic or video. The 10-year-old company has become synonymous with DIY design, serving as the preferred Instagram infographic app for the social justice “girlies.” Still, the app has plenty of overlooked features that Canvanauts (Canva’s word for its employees) use every day.

Keep Reading Show less
Lizzy Lawrence

Lizzy Lawrence ( @LizzyLaw_) is a reporter at Protocol, covering tools and productivity in the workplace. She's a recent graduate of the University of Michigan, where she studied sociology and international studies. She served as editor in chief of The Michigan Daily, her school's independent newspaper. She's based in D.C., and can be reached at llawrence@protocol.com.

Enterprise

GitHub’s CEO wants to go passwordless by 2025

Thomas Dohmke sat down with Protocol to talk about what the open-source code hosting site is doing to address security vulnerabilities, including an aim to go passwordless by 2025.

GitHub CEO Thomas Dohmke spoke to Protocol about its plan to go passwordless.

Photo: Vaughn Ridley/Sportsfile for Collision via Getty Images

GitHub CEO Thomas Dohmke wants to get rid of passwords.

Open-source software has been plagued with cybersecurity issues for years, and GitHub and other companies in the space have been taking steps to bolster security. Dohmke knows, however, that to get to the root of the industrywide problem will take more than just corporate action: It will ultimately require a sea change and cultural shift in how developers work.

Keep Reading Show less
Michelle Ma

Michelle Ma (@himichellema) is a reporter at Protocol, where she writes about management, leadership and workplace issues in tech. Previously, she was a news editor of live journalism and special coverage for The Wall Street Journal. Prior to that, she worked as a staff writer at Wirecutter. She can be reached at mma@protocol.com.

Latest Stories
Bulletins