Bulletins

ICE and DHS use Clearview AI, but won’t say how. They’re being sued for an answer.

A quartet of nonprofits have filed suit against the feds after their FOIA request about Clearview was ignored.

ICE and DHS use Clearview AI, but won’t say how. They’re being sued for an answer.

Four nonprofits are suing the Department of Homeland Security to find out how they use Clearview AI's facial recognition technology.

Photo: Lianhao Qu/Unsplash

The ACLU of Northern California and immigrant advocacy groups Just Futures Law, the Immigrant Defense Project and Mijente have filed suit against Immigration and Customs Enforcement, the Department of Homeland Security and Customs and Border Protection to gain access to any documents that show how and if they use Clearview AI's facial recognition software, after the government agencies did not respond to Freedom of Information Act requests.


Clearview AI provides software to match people's faces to billions of photographs and other personal information scraped from sites and services across the internet. The company has drawn criticism from across the political spectrum for gathering data without user consent, and is under investigation in the U.K., Australia and Europe for potentially violating privacy laws with its aggressive data-scraping policies.

The exact ways these federal agencies use Clearview's software are not public knowledge, but federal contracting records show the agencies have paid to have access. After the three groups requested that information through federal open records laws and were ignored, they filed suit in order to reveal how those contracts have been put into practice.

This lawsuit aims to ensure the public knows what these agencies are doing, and why (not whether their actions are illegal). "With this FOIA, we have a lot of questions. How is ICE using this? Who are they using it on? Are there any accountability measures in place?" said Sejal Zota, the co-founder and legal director of Just Futures. "At the very least, we want to know what's happening."

It became common practice under the Trump administration for DHS and its borders and customs enforcement agencies to regularly ignore or resist FOIA requests, according to Jennifer Jones, a technology and civil liberties fellow at the same ACLU office. While the Biden administration has expressed interest in more transparency and expediting requests, it's not unusual to have to sue these particular agencies to force them to comply with freedom of information laws, she said.

"They need to be providing information like this in a timely manner, and at this point it's been over five months," she said.

Surveillance technologies like Clearview AI could make it much easier for law enforcement agencies to track down people based on a name, address or even a grainy picture of a face, using data obtained without the consent of the person being tracked. "Clearview AI in our view is particularly concerning because they have expanded the reach of facial recognition so much by scraping and scanning billions of personal photos to create the massive database," said Vasudha Talla, the immigrant rights director for the ACLU of Northern California. "When you have a tool like this in the hands of ICE, DHS, CPB, obviously that raises concerns that when someone may post on the internet very naively, there is a chance that if ICE is using this tool as part of their immigration enforcement operation, that they could really be putting their family members or themselves at risk."

While the four groups are focusing mainly on the potential consequences for immigration and immigrant families in their suit, Talla suggested that because CBP has previously been known to deploy surveillance technologies against American citizens, the ACLU also has questions about whether this particular tool has been used for domestic surveillance.

Because the Biden administration has said it is conducting a full review of DHS's role in migrant detention, Mijente is hoping that forcing the agency to be transparent about this information will in turn cause the administration to pay more attention to how DHS uses surveillance technologies in its review, according to Jacinta Gonzalez, Mijente's field director.

"Clearview is the epitome of tech gone rogue, combined with policing gone rogue. In terms of how it's being used and how it's being implemented, it brings up really fundamental questions for us about not only facial recognition technology, and what happens to our information on the internet, and how easily that can be put in the hands of police," she said.

Latest Bulletins

David Hatfield has stepped down as co-CEO of cloud security vendor Lacework but will remain on the company's board of directors, Protocol has learned.

Keep Reading Show less

California’s new pay transparency law, SB 1162, promises to shake up compensation in the tech industry by requiring employers in the state to list pay scales in job ads and reveal pay information to both the state and to current employees. We spoke with Susan Alban, operating partner and chief people officer at Renegade Partners, and compensation consultant Ashish Raina to learn how.

Keep Reading Show less

Pour one out for the Lightning cable.

Keep Reading Show less

Carbon dioxide removal service buyers and sellers are focused on one metric: $100 per ton. It’s one of Frontier’s stated criteria that the fund uses to evaluate its advance purchases. In a survey of the long-duration carbon removal community, CarbonPlan found that stakeholders are focused on the $100 benchmark. The Department of Energy even announced that it would be investing in carbon removal research to bring the cost of the technology down to $100 per ton.

Keep Reading Show less

When Google announced the closure of its Stadia cloud gaming platform last week, the news was delivered at roughly the same time to employees, partners, and players on Thursday morning. Within hours, it had become clear that Stadia’s shutdown, planned for next January, would involve more than just refunding consumer purchases and quietly bowing out.

Now developers are scrambling to salvage planned projects, migrate players to other platforms, and figure out whether they’re still owed money from Google before the search giant puts Stadia out to pasture for good.

Keep Reading Show less

Trading of Twitter shares was briefly halted midday as CNBC and Bloomberg reported that Elon Musk now plans to go through with his deal to buy Twitter for $54.20 a share. The news was later confirmed.

Keep Reading Show less

The U.S. is set to unveil a fresh set of policies Thursday aimed at choking off China’s access to advanced chip manufacturing technology and the chips themselves, according to a person familiar with the matter.

Keep Reading Show less

Companies like Meta and Lyft have stopped hiring for the year, and that’s music to the ears of other tech companies that are still staffing up. Much of talent sourcing still takes place on LinkedIn, but many recruiters have found their own techniques to use the service more efficiently. We asked LinkedIn’s VP of talent acquisition and three outside recruiters for their best LinkedIn hacks for sourcing talent.

Keep Reading Show less

Kim Kardashian broke the internet, and according to the Securities and Exchange Commission, she also broke the securities laws.

Keep Reading Show less

On Thursday, California Gov. Gavin Newsom signed into law a bill that makes phone calls from California’s prisons free of charge. The new law places the cost of calls not on incarcerated people — or the people receiving calls from them — but on the state’s Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation.

California is the second state after Connecticut and the biggest state by far to institute such a law, which is a direct shot at the $1.4 billion prison telecom industry. For years prison telecom companies have maintained rates that “can be unjustly and unreasonably high, thereby impeding the ability of inmates and their loved ones to maintain vital connections,” the FCC said in 2020.

Prison reform advocates argue the new California law will have a hugely positive impact on the families of incarcerated people in California — and potentially other states that follow California's lead.

Keep Reading Show less

Rohit Chopra arrived as director of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau one year ago today. True to his reputation as an aggressive watchdog from his time as an FTC commissioner and an earlier stint at the CFPB, he has pursued a busy agenda that’s setting up regulatory battles to come.

Keep Reading Show less
Tech salaries are about to get a lot more transparent. On Tuesday, Gov. Gavin Newsom signed a new law to require California employers to post salary ranges in job postings and report hourly pay data by employees’ race and sex to the state. We spoke with four employment lawyers and other pay transparency experts about what this means, and how to comply.
Keep Reading Show less

Microsoft said Friday it's "working on an accelerated timeline" to provide a patch for two newly disclosed vulnerabilities affecting Exchange email servers, which the company acknowledged have been used in attacks on customers.

Keep Reading Show less

Google is stepping up its push for open video formats: The company plans to force hardware manufacturers to support the AV1 video codec if they want to run Android 14 on their mobile devices, according to comments left in recent commits to the Android Open Source Project (AOSP) that were first spotted by Esper senior technical editor Mishaal Rahman.

Keep Reading Show less

A troubling new vulnerability affecting Microsoft Exchange email servers has been disclosed by researchers, though details are still emerging on the severity and exploitability of the flaw.

Keep Reading Show less

The gas-powered vehicle ban dominoes have begun to fall.

Keep Reading Show less

Tech industry groups are once again pleading with the 5th Circuit to block HB 20, Texas' on-again, off-again social media law, which the court recently allowed to take effect.

Keep Reading Show less

Sometimes a major "hack" isn't really a hack at all, such as with some breaches caused by the mishandling of APIs.

Keep Reading Show less

The neobank MoneyLion charged service members excessive fees for loans and often refused to cancel paid memberships, according to a lawsuit filed Thursday by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.

Keep Reading Show less

Google is shutting down its Stadia cloud gaming service, nearly three years after its launch and roughly 18 months since the company shut down its internal game development division.

Keep Reading Show less

Amazon announced pay raises and the rollout of new benefit programs to warehouse employees Wednesday. But one of those products may pose increased risks to the company’s most precarious workers: the expanded rollout of Amazon’s Anytime Pay Program.

Keep Reading Show less

More pay transparency is coming to California. The Golden State is joining New York City, Colorado, and Washington in requiring employers to disclose pay ranges in job ads.

Keep Reading Show less

Cost-cutting in tech is officially hitting the industry’s titans. After years of ruthless staffing up, both Meta and Google have told some employees to find new jobs within the company or leave, according to a report in The Wall Street Journal.

Keep Reading Show less

Calendly, the $3 billion scheduling startup that everyone likes to periodically fight about, has made its first acquisition: Prelude, a startup specializing in the hiring process. Prelude is specifically geared toward scheduling job interviews or other types of recruitment-related meetings.

Keep Reading Show less

Celsius Network CEO Alex Mashinsky resigned from the embattled cryptocurrency lender Tuesday morning. The lender is in the middle of bankruptcy proceedings after pausing withdrawals in June.

Keep Reading Show less
Bulletins