Bulletins

NY AG finds nearly 82% of net neutrality comments to the FCC were fake

NY AG finds nearly 82% of net neutrality comments to the FCC were fake

NY Attorney General Letitia James

(Photo by Joshua Rashaad McFadden/Getty Images)

In a new report, New York Attorney General Letitia James found that of the more than 22 million public comments the Federal Communications Commission received in 2017 regarding the repeal of net neutrality protections, a whopping 18 million were fake. Millions of those comments, the report says, were funded by the broadband industry.


"The OAG found that millions of fake comments were submitted through a secret campaign, funded by the country's largest broadband companies, to manufacture support for the repeal of existing net neutrality rules using lead generators," the report says. "And millions more were submitted by a 19- year old college student using made-up identities."

The investigators behind the report found that nearly 80% of the comments funded by the broadband industry were collected by lead generation companies that offered consumers various rewards in exchange for their information. "Marketing offers varied widely, and included everything from discounted children's movies to free trials of male enhancement products," the report reads. The broadband industry would then run additional solicitations alongside those promotions, asking consumers to join the anti-net neutrality campaign, according to the report.

But the lead generation companies did not always run those solicitations, the report says. "Instead, they copied names and addresses they had purchased or collected months or years earlier through unrelated lead generation efforts, and passed it off as information submitted by consumers who had agreed to join the broadband industry's campaign," it reads.

One lead generator went so far as to use information obtained through a data breach to submit fake comments.

According to the report, some lead generators went to great lengths to conceal their scheme from Broadband For America, the broadband-funded non-profit group that orchestrated the campaign. In one instance, the report cites a message from an employee at the lead generation company, Fluent. In it, the employee asks a colleague to post one of the net neutrality solicitations on a dummy site that did not receive any actual live traffic or generate any leads, shortly before a call with Fluent's client, Broadband for America. "I have to jump on a call with [the client] to prove our process is legit this morning," the message, cited in the report reads.

The report alleges that Fluent did not in fact run any of Broadband for America's actual solicitations regarding net neutrality along with its marketing offers, "and, accordingly, never obtained anyone's consent to submit comments to the FCC."

The AG's office reached agreements with three of the lead generation companies, Fluent, Opt-Intelligence and React2Media, which collectively agreed to pay more than $4 million in damages. Investigators did not find that the broadband providers behind the campaign violated the law. But, the report said, "Red flags were ignored by the campaign organizers and the way that they conducted their campaign — hiding the broadband industry's involvement, relying on lead generators that used commercial incentives to lure people to comment, and paying dubious vendors for volume rather than quality — is troubling and raises important policy questions."

The 18 million fake comments the FCC received did not solely oppose net neutrality. The 19-year-old college student cited in the report submitted 7.7 million comments in favor of net neutrality. "The FCC had few safeguards in place to detect or prevent millions of submissions from a single source," the report reads. "The OAG also identified another group of 1.6 million pro-neutrality comments that were submitted using fictitious identities, but has not determined the source of these comments."

Under former FCC chairman Ajit Pai, the FCC repealed Obama-era net neutrality protections. In the report, the investigators argue that the deluge of fake comments may have had "significant consequences" for the FCC's decision. "Federal and state agencies rely on public comments to set standards that govern many aspects of our lives, from public health to consumer protection to the environment, and, in this case, the rules that govern how we share and consume content over the internet," the report reads. "Public comments can also influence legislators and the laws they enact."




Latest Bulletins

China plans to build enough charging stations for 20 million electric vehicles by 2025, according to a new document by the National Development and Reform Commission and nine other ministries. The government will offer direct financial subsidies and encourage favorable banking policies for companies to build charging facilities.

Keep Reading Show less

Developers at Raven Software, a subsidiary of Activision Blizzard, have formed a union with a supermajority of quality assurance workers after five weeks of striking, just days after Microsoft announced it would be acquiring Activision Blizzard for nearly $70 billion.

Keep Reading Show less

By establishing an opaque corporate structure and avoding detailed questions from partners, regulators and law enforcement, Binance is dodging many of the rules other financial firms are forced to follow. That’s according to a new Reuters investigation, which reviewed dozens of private documents including copies of encrypted Telegram messages, internal regulatory reports and letters sent by law enforcement.

Keep Reading Show less

Hank Green doesn’t think creators on TikTok are getting paid well enough, and he doesn’t think the majority of the people on TikTok even realize it, the vlogger explained in a YouTube video on Thursday.

Keep Reading Show less

Robinhood said it has started rolling out its much-awaited crypto wallets in a move that’s expected to boost its reach in the fast-growing market.

Keep Reading Show less

IBM announced today that it has sold its Watson Health data and analytics assets to private equity firm Francisco Partners. The highly anticipated sell-off includes data sets and analytics products such as Health Insights, MarketScan, Clinical Development, Social Program Management, Micromedex and imaging software offerings.

Keep Reading Show less

Intel plans to invest $20 billion in building out a 1,000-acre chip manufacturing mega site outside of Columbus, Ohio, the company said Friday, a project it said would create 3,000 permanent jobs in the region.

Keep Reading Show less

Twitter's new CEO has continued to shake up company leadership, announcing Wednesday that both Rinki Sethi and Peiter Zatko — better known as Mudge — would leave their roles as chief information security officer and head of Security, respectively.

Keep Reading Show less

Twitter announced Thursday that some Twitter Blue subscribers can now use one of their NFTs as their profile photo, as long as they're willing to connect their crypto wallet to their Twitter account.

Keep Reading Show less

A Tesla employee at the company's Fremont factory died on Wednesday while working on its production line.

Keep Reading Show less

Microsoft's purchase of Activision Blizzard this week has proven to be among the most consequential acquisition announcements in the history of the game industry, and it's proved equally controversial when considering what it means for big game franchises like Call of Duty. Now, Xbox chief Phil Spencer, CEO of the newly formed Microsoft Gaming division, has come out with a public statement affirming Microsoft's position on multi-platform support for the shooter series, though with a fair amount of ambiguity thrown in.

Keep Reading Show less

The Federal Reserve released a long-awaited review of the potential for creating a central bank digital currency Thursday, after months of delays. Ahead of making a decision, the Fed has asked the public to submit answers on 22 questions posed in the report.

Keep Reading Show less

TikTok ousted its Nick Tran, its global head of marketing, The Information reported. The reason for his departure was not made clear.

Keep Reading Show less

Know someone in the market for a few hundred boxes of alcohol wipes, thousands of bottles of hand sanitizer or some bulletproof glass partitions? Meta is selling all this and more at its Menlo Park headquarters in an auction closing Thursday. (What, the company didn't think it could move it on Facebook Marketplace?)

Keep Reading Show less

New York City Mayor Eric Adams will receive his first paycheck in bitcoin and ethereum, highlighting his bid to turn the Big Apple into a major crypto hub.

Keep Reading Show less

The game industry as a whole is slowly but surely beginning to call for systemic change to business practices and workplace culture norms, and developers are now more than ever before looking at unionization as the tool for doing so, according to a new survey.

Keep Reading Show less

Amazon is digging deeper into the physical storefront. The tech giant is opening a real-world clothing store called Amazon Style in Los Angeles later this year, the company announced Thursday.

Keep Reading Show less

Shanghai’s municipal government on Wednesday announced new policies meant to bolster China’s advanced chipmaking capabilities.

Keep Reading Show less

Google is testing the waters with bitcoin as cryptocurrency starts to become more widely adopted.

The tech giant is enabling digital cards that store cryptocurrencies to be used on Google Pay, through partnerships with Coinbase, BitPay and Gemini, the company said. The news was earlier reported by Bloomberg.

Keep Reading Show less

After shutting down withdrawals due to suspicious activity, Crypto.com CEO Kris Marszalek confirmed to Bloomberg that the exchanged experienced a security breach affecting 400 accounts on Tuesday.

Keep Reading Show less

Instagram is trying out a new way for creators to get paid. Following in the footsteps of Twitter's nascent "Super Follow" feature, Instagram is testing creator subscriptions, allowing a select few to offer followers paid access to exclusive content.

Keep Reading Show less

The exclusive maker of the machines used to fabricate the world’s most advanced chips gave us a bit of rare good news about the global shortage of microprocessors Wednesday.

Keep Reading Show less

In her first TV interview since becoming chair of the Federal Trade Commission, Lina Khan had a message for business executives who think their money, lawyers and lobbyists will shield them from antitrust scrutiny: "Enforcers are not gonna back down."

Keep Reading Show less

Revolut is rolling out commission-free stock trading in the U.S., highlighting the U.K. mobile banking company’s bid to become a “global financial super app.” The move is also a direct challenge to major online brokerages led by Robinhood. Shares of Robinhood slipped 2% in late morning trading.

Keep Reading Show less

Activision Blizzard has been embroiled in a sexism and workplace discrimination crisis for the past six months, the effects of which directly led to the announcement on Tuesday that Microsoft plans to buy the publisher for a record-breaking $68.7 billion, according to a report from The Wall Street Journal.

Keep Reading Show less
Bulletins