Protocol | Fintech

SEC chair Gary Gensler: Conflict 'inherent' in payment for order flow

The newly appointed stock-market regulator criticized the practice that has made zero-commission stock trading possible, saying investors are paid in other ways.

​SEC chair Gary Gensler testifies at a House Financial Services Committee hearing on Thursday, May 6, 2021.

SEC chair Gary Gensler testifies at a House Financial Services Committee hearing.

Screenshot: House Financial Services Committee/YouTube

SEC Chairman Gary Gensler, only a few weeks on the job, told members of Congress on Thursday that he's looking closely at payment for order flow and market concentration with an eye toward whether retail traders are getting a fair shake.

Gensler highlighted his agency's increased scrutiny of the markets at a hearing of the House Financial Services Committee about January's wild gyrations in GameStop shares.

Payment for order flow was an area of particular interest to committee members. Some brokers like Robinhood use the now-widespread practice to get paid by market makers for sending trades to them. Critics question whether such payments set up a conflict of interest and deprive retail investors of the best possible price for shares; proponents say that market makers deliver considerable improvement in prices.

The House committee has a draft discussion proposal to ban payment for order flow. Canada and the United Kingdom don't allow it, and a U.K. study found that the country's elimination of the practice resulted in better prices for investors.

"I've asked staff to take a closer look at this in the context of overall market structure," Gensler said. Such payments, he said, can be a "conflict with the interest" of customers and such conflicts are an "inherent" part of the system.

Payment for order flow's supporters have argued that retail traders benefit from the elimination of commissions such payments make possible. Gensler seemed unpersuaded by those arguments.

"These are not free apps. They're just zero-commission apps," he said. "The cost is inside the order execution."

Gensler also cited the Robinhood case settled in December — though he didn't name the popular online brokerage — as an example of the ability of brokers to define for themselves how much of the profit from the spread they get and how much they pass on to investors as price improvement.

"We found conflict in various enforcement cases like one we filed where the wholesaler was literally saying, 'Well, you tell me. I can pay you more — the broker — or I can pay the customer more.' We know at least from that case this inherent conflict is there," he said.

In that settlement, the SEC wrote: "[C]ertain of the principal trading firms told Robinhood that there was a trade-off between payment for order flow on the one hand and price improvement on the other: If Robinhood negotiated for higher payment for order flow revenue, according to the principal trading firms, there would be less money available for the principal trading firms to provide price improvement to Robinhood's customers."

But payment for order flow is not the whole story when it comes to best execution, Gensler said. He noted that wholesalers — which are not regulated like "lit" exchanges — have 37% to 38% of the market. The SEC is also looking at exchange rebates that the exchanges pay to brokers, which function similarly to payment for order flow, Gensler said.

Several representatives asked about system risk and the concentration of power in trading, and some asked specifically about Citadel's role as the largest market maker.

The current market structure has also led to market concentration, which can mean higher costs for investors, Gensler said. While he didn't cite scrutiny of specific firms, that could mean a closer look at firms such as Citadel, which says it is the largest wholesaler, executing 47% of U.S.-listed retail trades.

Gensler said he had asked commission staff to review "how this market structure that's led to concentration — right now we have pretty highly concentrated and growing concentration in the retail order flow. Economics tells us competition lowers cost to investors."

Short of a ban on payment for order flow, regulators said that increased disclosure about payment for order flow is also a possibility. "Fundamentally the question is, is that conflict you're describing, is that adequately addressed through disclosure?" said Robert Cook, president and CEO of FINRA. "Many investors don't understand these aspects of the market."

One infrastructure issue that regulators are looking at is reducing the settlement time for trades from two days to one. The technology to do this is already available, Gensler said. This could lower certain margin and volatility costs as much as 40%, saving the industry $6 billion a day, and the Depository Trust and Clearing Corporation is looking at different ways to do this along with industry partners, said Michael Bodson, CEO of DTCC.

Gensler also said he would look at gamification and its role in trading, noting that he's fine with a streaming service manipulating him to watch more movies — he's partial to romantic comedies, he noted — but that manipulating people to trade more isn't necessarily a good thing.

"If you use gamification features and folks are trading more actively and day trading, then all of a sudden that's their investment future," he said. "That's a challenge for their future and security. I think we have to take a look at this."

Protocol | Policy

5 things to know about FCC nominee Gigi Sohn

The veteran of some of the earliest tech policy fights is a longtime consumer champion and net-neutrality advocate.

Gigi Sohn, who President Joe Biden nominated to serve on the FCC, is a longtime net-neutrality advocate.

Photo: Alex Wong/Getty Images

President Joe Biden on Tuesday nominated Gigi Sohn to serve as a Federal Communications Commissioner, teeing up a Democratic majority at the agency that oversees broadband issues after months of delay.

Like Lina Khan, who Biden picked in June to head up the Federal Trade Commission, Sohn is a progressive favorite. And if confirmed, she'll take up a position in an agency trying to pull policy levers on net neutrality, privacy and broadband access even as Congress is stalled.

Keep Reading Show less
Ben Brody

Ben Brody (@ BenBrodyDC) is a senior reporter at Protocol focusing on how Congress, courts and agencies affect the online world we live in. He formerly covered tech policy and lobbying (including antitrust, Section 230 and privacy) at Bloomberg News, where he previously reported on the influence industry, government ethics and the 2016 presidential election. Before that, Ben covered business news at CNNMoney and AdAge, and all manner of stories in and around New York. He still loves appearing on the New York news radio he grew up with.

If you've ever tried to pick up a new fitness routine like running, chances are you may have fallen into the "motivation vs. habit" trap once or twice. You go for a run when the sun is shining, only to quickly fall off the wagon when the weather turns sour.

Similarly, for many businesses, 2020 acted as the storm cloud that disrupted their plans for innovation. With leaders busy grappling with the pandemic, innovation frequently got pushed to the backburner. In fact, according to McKinsey, the majority of organizations shifted their focus mainly to maintaining business continuity throughout the pandemic.

Keep Reading Show less
Gaurav Kataria
Group Product Manager, Trello at Atlassian
Protocol | Workplace

Adobe wants a more authentic NFT world

Adobe's Content Credentials feature will allow Creative Cloud subscribers to attach edit-tracking information to Photoshop files. The goal is to create a more trustworthy NFT market and digital landscape.

Adobe's Content Credentials will allow users to attach their identities to an image

Image: Adobe

Remember the viral, fake photo of Kurt Cobain and Biggie Smalls that duped and delighted the internet in 2017? Doctored images manipulate people and erode trust and we're not great at spotting them. The entire point of the emerging NFT art market is to create valuable and scarce digital files and when there isn't an easy way to check for an image's origin and edits, there's a problem. What if someone steals an NFT creator's image and pawns it off as their own? As a hub for all kinds of multimedia, Adobe feels a responsibility to combat misinformation and provide a safe space for NFT creators. That's why it's rolling out Content Credentials, a record that can be attached to a Photoshop file of a creator's identity and includes any edits they made.

Users can connect their social media addresses and crypto wallet addresses to images in Photoshop. This further proves the image creator's identity, but it's also helpful in determining the creators of NFTs. Adobe has partnered with NFT marketplaces KnownOrigin, OpenSea, Rarible and SuperRare in this effort. "Today there's not a way to know that the NFT you're buying was actually created by a true creator," said Adobe General Counsel Dana Rao. "We're allowing the creator to show their identity and attach it to the image."

Keep Reading Show less
Lizzy Lawrence

Lizzy Lawrence ( @LizzyLaw_) is a reporter at Protocol, covering tools and productivity in the workplace. She's a recent graduate of the University of Michigan, where she studied sociology and international studies. She served as editor in chief of The Michigan Daily, her school's independent newspaper. She's based in D.C., and can be reached at llawrence@protocol.com.

Protocol | China

Why another Chinese lesbian dating app just shut down

With neither political support nor a profitable business model, lesbian dating apps are finding it hard to survive in China.

Operating a dating app for LGBTQ+ communities in China is like walking a tightrope.

Photo: Nicolas Asfouri/AFP via Getty Images

When Lesdo, a Chinese dating app designed for lesbian women, announced it was closing down, it didn't come as a surprise to the LGBTQ+ community.

It's unclear what directly caused this decision. 2021 hasn't been kind to China's queer communities; WeChat has deactivated queer groups' public accounts and Beijing has pressured charity organizations not to work with queer activists.

Keep Reading Show less
Zeyi Yang
Zeyi Yang is a reporter with Protocol | China. Previously, he worked as a reporting fellow for the digital magazine Rest of World, covering the intersection of technology and culture in China and neighboring countries. He has also contributed to the South China Morning Post, Nikkei Asia, Columbia Journalism Review, among other publications. In his spare time, Zeyi co-founded a Mandarin podcast that tells LGBTQ stories in China. He has been playing Pokemon for 14 years and has a weird favorite pick.

The Oura Ring was a sleep-tracking hit. Can the next one be even more?

Oura wants to be a media company, an activity tracker and even a way to know you're sick before you feel sick.

Over the last few years, the Oura Ring has become one of the most recognizable wearables this side of the Apple Watch.

Photo: Oura

Oura CEO Harpreet Rai swears he didn't know Kim Kardashian was a fan. He was as surprised as anyone when she started posting screenshots from the Oura app to her Instagram story, and got into a sleep battle with fellow Oura user Gwyneth Paltrow. Or when Jennifer Aniston revealed that Jimmy Kimmel got her hooked on Oura … and how her ring fell off in a salad. "I am addicted to it," Aniston said, "and it's ruining my life" by shaming her about her lack of sleep. "I think we're definitely seeing traction outside of tech," Rai said. "Which is cool."

Over the last couple of years, Oura's ring (imaginatively named the Oura Ring) has become one of the most recognizable wearables this side of the Apple Watch. The company started with a Kickstarter campaign in 2015, but really started to find traction with its second-generation model in 2018. It's not exactly a mainstream device — Oura said it has sold more than 500,000 rings, up from 150,000 in March 2020 but still not exactly Apple Watch levels — but it has reached some of the most successful, influential and probably sleep-deprived people in the industry. Jack Dorsey is a professed fan, as is Marc Benioff.

Keep Reading Show less
David Pierce

David Pierce ( @pierce) is Protocol's editorial director. Prior to joining Protocol, he was a columnist at The Wall Street Journal, a senior writer with Wired, and deputy editor at The Verge. He owns all the phones.

Latest Stories