Fintech

The hunt for Russian crypto is on

The blockchain never forgets, and crypto isn’t as anonymous as you think.

Russian crypto coin running from magnifying glass

There’s no such thing as complete anonymity on a blockchain.

Illustration: Christopher T. Fong/Protocol

Finding yachts is pretty easy. At least two belonging to sanctioned allies of Vladimir Putin were confiscated last week, and the locations of others are known to authorities.

The hunt for Russian crypto is trickier. But it turns out to be harder to hide than Russian oligarchs might think.

The push to penalize Russia for invading Ukraine is the first major sanctions campaign aimed at “financially destabilizing a head of state” by targeting digital assets, said Michael Fasanello, chief compliance officer of LVL, a banking and crypto trading company.

But it’s not the first sanctions program to take crypto into account. The Trump administration banned U.S. transactions based on the petro, the digital currency issued by the Venezuelan government under President Nicolás Maduro.

That campaign, Fasanello said, was “miniscule compared to the attack on digital assets focused on Putin and his oligarchy.”

The start of the invasion was reportedly followed by a spike in crypto trades involving the Russian ruble, which some took as a sign that oligarchs might be trying to use digital currencies to evade sanctions.

The U.S. Treasury’s Office of Foreign Assets Control tightened its rules this month to make clear that sanctions against Russia included digital assets. Last week, Senate Democrats led by Elizabeth Warren raised concerns with the Treasury Department that Russian oligarchs could be using crypto for “nefarious purposes.” And on Monday, FinCEN specifically warned that sanctioned individuals and entities in Russia and Belarus might be using “convertible virtual currencies” to evade restrictions.

Crypto crime is real, and large: It hit $14 billion last year, according to Chainalysis, up from $7.8 billion in 2020. It also has the unique aspect of happening in plain sight. Unlike fiat money laundered through a series of opaque shell-company transactions, every crypto transfer is recorded permanently on the blockchain. It’s just a question of whether authorities can link those transactions to a real identity.

Oligarchs can hide their crypto. Moving it is another matter.

There’s no such thing as complete anonymity on a blockchain. A crypto account or wallet, which is typically identified as a series of numbers and letters, is visible to a network. Even though no names or any other info is visible, pretty much all transactions can be tracked.

“Ultimately, crypto is very easy to track, whether it’s decentralized or centralized,” said Steven Waterhouse, CEO of Orchid Labs.

To monitor accounts and transactions, all you need is a wallet address. “With that, you can see how much is in the crypto accounts,” Marco Bellin, founder and CEO of Datacappy, told Protocol. “There is a trail that can be followed. Every transaction that an identified account has with another account is noted and can be traced.”

Tigran Gambaryan, vice president of Global Intelligence and Investigations at Binance, said crypto is “a terrible thing to use to evade sanctions” because “everybody looks at these transactions,” which makes it extremely difficult when you’re trying to move large amounts of money.

FinCEN noted in its Monday alert that “large-scale sanctions evasion using convertible virtual currency by a government such as the Russian Federation is not necessarily practicable.”

But Fasanello observed that “crypto permits pseudo-anonymity,” which, when combined with tools for obfuscating transactions, “can present a very difficult situation for investigators — even using best-in-class blockchain analytics.”

It is possible to protect a crypto wallet from scrutiny by taking it offline. That typically means using a hardware wallet — also referred to as a cold wallet — that is not constantly connected to a blockchain network.

But that means an oligarch wouldn’t be able to do anything with the crypto. “If you have some crypto and you want to store it in a cold wallet, then it would come down to when you want it to move and how you want to process it at that point,” Waterhouse said.

And that won’t be easy, especially if they’re moving huge amounts.

“If they're sending to an unhosted wallet, we're not always going to know who controls that on the back end,” Nirvana Patel, chief compliance officer of Prime Trust, a digital assets infrastructure software company, told Protocol.

But once they try to move funds, the wallet will become visible to the network. And those connections can be traced — a “six degrees of Kevin Bacon kind of thing,” Patel said. “You're going to know that someone is connected to something down the chain at some point.”

The tools to hide crypto aren’t perfect

Money launderers use blockchain-based tools known as tumblers or mixers to obfuscate transactions. The idea is to pool coins to be transferred, breaking the origin and destination chain and enabling crypto users to cover their tracks.

But these tools are typically slow and “expensive to use,” Gambaryan of Binance said. “And they're not very efficient if you're trying to move around billions or hundreds of millions of dollars because they're not built to process those kinds of transactions … They're built to actually transfer small amounts. And if you actually try to move large amounts, it's actually very easy to break through tumblers.”

Waterhouse agreed, saying, “for the scale of what we're talking about … these tools are not really sufficient.”

Some crypto exchanges have blocked withdrawals to mixing services.

The blockchain never forgets

Crypto technology continues to evolve. And transactions made stealthily now could come back to haunt sanctions evaders years later.

“The scary thing about this stuff for bad actors is it's not like you get away with it and then someone forgets about it,” Waterhouse said. “The tools are getting better. And then a few years later, someone's like, ‘Oh, actually, I figured out who did that and I can go back and trace it.’”

But the flip side is also true, argued Fasanello. With the resources they have, oligarchs can gain access to “the finest of hackers to discover new ways to game the system.”

“The oligarchs have been perfecting the skill of hiding assets and obfuscating the course of funds for a very long time,” he said. “Marry this skill set with cutting-edge tech, and you have one heck of a fight on your hands as a counter-[financial crime] professional.”

But even the slightest slip-up can unravel years of secrecy. A $500 Walmart gift card helped lead investigators to the couple accused of laundering $4.5 billion stolen in the Bitfinex hack. Ultimately, crypto is safest when it’s hidden. And oligarchs have a tendency to display their wealth — like those yachts being seized around the world.

Workplace

An IPO may soon be in Notion’s future

Notion COO Akshay Kothari says there’s room to grow, aided by a new CFO who knows how to take a company public.

Notion has hired its first chief financial officer: Rama Katkar.

Photo: Courtesy of Notion

It’s been a year since Notion’s triumphant $275 million funding round and $10 billion valuation. Since then the landscape for productivity startups trying to make it on their own has completely changed, especially for those pandemic darlings that flourished in the all-remote world.

As recession looms, companies looking to cut costs are less likely to spend money on tools outside of their Microsoft or Google workplace bundles. Enterprise platforms are bulking up and it could spell trouble for the productivity startups trying to unseat them. But Notion COO Akshay Kothari says the company is still aiming to build the next Microsoft, not be the next Microsoft. And in a move signaling a new chapter of maturity, Notion has hired its first chief financial officer: Rama Katkar, Instacart’s former VP of finance.

Keep Reading Show less
Lizzy Lawrence

Lizzy Lawrence ( @LizzyLaw_) is a reporter at Protocol, covering tools and productivity in the workplace. She's a recent graduate of the University of Michigan, where she studied sociology and international studies. She served as editor in chief of The Michigan Daily, her school's independent newspaper. She's based in D.C., and can be reached at llawrence@protocol.com.

Sponsored Content

Great products are built on strong patents

Experts say robust intellectual property protection is essential to ensure the long-term R&D required to innovate and maintain America's technology leadership.

Every great tech product that you rely on each day, from the smartphone in your pocket to your music streaming service and navigational system in the car, shares one important thing: part of its innovative design is protected by intellectual property (IP) laws.

From 5G to artificial intelligence, IP protection offers a powerful incentive for researchers to create ground-breaking products, and governmental leaders say its protection is an essential part of maintaining US technology leadership. To quote Secretary of Commerce Gina Raimondo: "intellectual property protection is vital for American innovation and entrepreneurship.”

Keep Reading Show less
James Daly
James Daly has a deep knowledge of creating brand voice identity, including understanding various audiences and targeting messaging accordingly. He enjoys commissioning, editing, writing, and business development, particularly in launching new ventures and building passionate audiences. Daly has led teams large and small to multiple awards and quantifiable success through a strategy built on teamwork, passion, fact-checking, intelligence, analytics, and audience growth while meeting budget goals and production deadlines in fast-paced environments. Daly is the Editorial Director of 2030 Media and a contributor at Wired.
Securing the Enterprise

Securing the enterprise

There’s no let-up in the surge of cyberattacks against businesses. But shutting down the hackers will require many enterprises to evolve their strategy.

In today’s enterprise, “identity and security are very merged.”

Illustration: iStock/Getty Images Plus; Protocol
the Protocol team
Protocol focuses on the people, power and politics of tech, with no agenda and just one goal: to arm decision-makers in tech, business and public policy with the unbiased, fact-based news and analysis they need to navigate a world in rapid change.
Fintech

How neobanks are helping consumers game credit scoring

The CFPB says it is closely monitoring secured credit cards offered by neobanks.

Regulators are scrutinizing neobanks' card offerings.

Photo: Oscar Wong/Moment/Getty Images

About one in six Americans has a credit score below 619, according to the CFPB. Another 23% have too thin a credit file to score or no file at all. That puts them in a credit trap: To build credit, these consumers need someone to give them a line of credit with which they can demonstrate good financial habits. But with scores that low, few lenders are prepared to offer them anything.

Neobanks say they can solve the problem through a new twist on secured credit cards. But regulators are already scrutinizing their offerings.

Keep Reading Show less
Veronica Irwin

Veronica Irwin (@vronirwin) is a San Francisco-based reporter at Protocol covering fintech. Previously she was at the San Francisco Examiner, covering tech from a hyper-local angle. Before that, her byline was featured in SF Weekly, The Nation, Techworker, Ms. Magazine and The Frisc.

Policy

Steel decided World War II. Chips will decide whatever is next.

“Chip War: The Fight for the World’s Most Critical Technology” foreshadows the coming battle between nations over semiconductors.

“Chip War” outlines the nature of the coming battle over semiconductors, showing how the power to produce leading-edge chips fell into the hands of just five companies.

Image: Scribner; Protocol

“World War II was decided by steel and aluminum, and followed shortly thereafter by the Cold War, which was defined by atomic weapons,” Chris Miller, a professor at Tufts University’s Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy, writes in the introduction to his latest book. So what’s next? According to Miller, the next era, including the rivalry between the U.S. and China, is all about computing power.

That tech rivalry and the story of how the chip industry got from four to 11.8 billion transistors are all part of Miller’s book, “Chip War: The Fight for the World’s Most Critical Technology,” which comes out Oct. 4. “Chip War” outlines the nature of the coming battle over semiconductors, showing how the power to produce leading-edge chips fell into the hands of just five companies: three from the U.S., one from Japan, and one from the Netherlands.

Keep Reading Show less
Hirsh Chitkara

Hirsh Chitkara ( @HirshChitkara) is a reporter at Protocol focused on the intersection of politics, technology and society. Before joining Protocol, he helped write a daily newsletter at Insider that covered all things Big Tech. He's based in New York and can be reached at hchitkara@protocol.com.

Latest Stories
Bulletins