Get access to Protocol
Wealthfront is embracing crypto. Is there a safe way to invest?
"We want to do it in a way that helps clients, as opposed to gambling," says co-founder Dan Carroll.
Wealthfront co-founder Dan Carroll typically describes the company's investing approach as focusing on carefully considered financial goals, "as opposed to gambling."
Launched in 2008 at the height of the financial crisis, Wealthfront now has more than 440,000 clients and manages more than $25 billion in assets thanks to its role as a pioneer in the use of roboadvisor investing software.
It also became famous for encouraging clients to embrace a long-term, conservative approach to investing. So it wasn't surprising that when bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies hit the scene, Wealthfront didn't rush to offer the volatile and risky assets.
That's about to change.
Wealthfront announced in late April that it has begun exploring cryptocurrencies as an investment option for clients. Though Carroll said Wealthfront came to the decision on its own, it comes at a time when crypto has become more widely accepted, highlighted by the successful public-market debut of crypto marketplace Coinbase.
In an interview with Protocol, Carroll, now the company's chief strategy officer, talked about why Wealthfront decided to embrace crypto investing and how it fits into the company's wealth management philosophy.
This interview has been edited for clarity and brevity.
How did you reach the decision to add crypto to the Wealthfront platform?
What we noticed was clients are getting more and more interested in the markets. At this time in the pandemic, everyone was home. There was a stock-trading craze. The interest in the market is really at an all-time high, and Wealthfront can really add value to this.
Wealthfront is a fiduciary so we have to do what's in your best interest. Where some of these young folks may be interested in the stock market, and they go on some of these gambling platforms to buy stocks or buy AMC, Wealthfront actually has to do what's in your best interest. So, as we add more options, such as crypto, to the platform, we do it in a way that's in your best interest.
The core Wealthfront classic portfolio that we recommend to clients won't likely offer crypto. But the clients can customize their portfolio based on their goals and where they want to go in life. They can choose to add different securities and ETFs and later crypto to their portfolio. We saw this interest and the knowledge being there and we thought, "Well, Wealthfront is the best fiduciary that's positioned to actually guide people to do what's best, where they can dip their toe into something like crypto, but do it in a responsible way."
You were founded in 2008, when bitcoin was literally just a white paper. How did your view of cryptocurrencies evolve?
We believe that the best way to build long-term wealth is in a diversified portfolio, low-cost index funds over a long period of time. We want to give clients the ability to invest in what they believe in, whether that's socially responsible, whether that's crypto and stuff of that nature. As new kinds of investing trends hit the market, we don't need to be first. As something newer like crypto [emerges], we're heads-down trying to do what's in the clients' best interest and let that market develop. A decade later, as it's become more accepted, we're at the point where we can make recommendations, where we can help people manage the risk and add crypto to their portfolios. But we don't need to be trailblazers in that regard.
How did your team discuss the pros and cons of adding crypto?
As a fiduciary, as we offer something like crypto, it's likely that there would be some type of limit to how much you can have in your portfolio. The discussions at Wealthfront, as we launch into this exploratory phase, are around what exposure do we offer clients, whether they can have 10% in crypto and something like that. Many on the team [with] their own Coinbase accounts were super interested in crypto. The interest among our employees is really high. Doing it in a way that can actually help clients and not be gambling, we're super interested in.
What currencies are going to be added? Are you adding Bitcoin?
We're in the exploratory phase, so we haven't announced the partnership that we're having, or the exact coins that we're offering. What we had said is, it's likely that we'd offer Bitcoin and [Ether]. Any details outside of that, you know, we don't have anything to announce.
How are you tackling this change, given the volatile nature of these assets?
We have a team of Ph.D.s in our investment team. There are different volatilities in different asset classes. You can imagine that the volatility of something like crypto would be higher than, let's say, the volatility of something like U.S. stocks. Given that, it will have a different place in the diversified portfolio than, say, U.S. stocks. As stuff is more volatile, it's likely it's going to be a lesser percentage of your portfolio.
We offer you a recommended portfolio based on your risk. As they add securities to their portfolio and access to something like crypto, we will show them how their risk changes. Let's say that your risk score is seven and you now want to own an innovation ETF and have some type of access to crypto, and now, your risk score is eight — we will let you know. "Hey, Ben, your risk is going to increase by doing this. Are you OK with that?" So we'll guide clients in that regard.
How do you view the trend of crypto ETFs?
There's a lot of crypto ETFs that are in the [regulatory] pipeline. They haven't been approved yet. We would welcome that. We want to be able to provide low-cost products to our clients and so any products that are good products that can lower the cost of crypto we would welcome.
How did recent developments in crypto, such as the Coinbase IPO or the rise of Dogecoin, impact this decision?
They didn't play a role. I mean, it is fun watching Elon Musk tweeting about Dogecoin, [but] it played no role in offering [crypto] to Wealthfront clients. It's more the demand.
Has Dogecoin been mentioned as a possible addition?
Not at this time.
I don't know. You tell me.
Do you invest in crypto, Dan?
I do. Very small amounts.
Bitcoin, yes. I haven't actually done it in a while. It's been a couple years but I do remember buying it at $500 and selling it at $1,800 and that was about it. I haven't played with it in years.
What are your worst fears about this move?
I don't have fears.
That's another way of asking: How do you prepare for the unexpected?
We think in terms of decades and not years when it comes to asset-class returns. You know one asset class is hot, the other is not, and that's why you have rebalancing. We think in terms of asset-class returns in terms of decades. If it's a part of a diversified portfolio and it's a small part of a diversified portfolio, sometimes it's going to help, but sometimes it's going to hurt over a long period of time. We think that we can do it in a responsible way where clients can still reach their goals and have access to crypto. We just want to do it in a way that actually helps clients reach goals as opposed to gambling.
Speaking of gambling, retail investing recently was in the spotlight with the GameStop and Robinhood trading frenzy. How do you reflect on that controversy?
One of the benefits of the recent focus on the market is there's 130 million millennials and Gen Z out there that have an interest in investing that they may not have had before. For young, first-time investors in the stock market, they are getting into it from the meme level. But a lot of them are realizing, "You know, this gambling thing isn't for me." From our perspective, an awareness perspective, this is great for Wealthfront. A lot of people will try their hand at buying the AMCs of the world and the GameStops of the world and realize, "You know, maybe this was fun with my play money, but I kind of want to get serious and I just got burned." A long-term option like Wealthfront actually is in your best interest.
What are you most worried about in fintech, specifically the space you're in, investing?
I think it's the exact opposite. What we're actually seeing is a golden age in fintech. It's never been a better time to be a consumer. If you think about the past decades, we haven't seen any banking innovation since the ATM. Now we have a lot of these new fintech companies, and they're building great product experiences on your phone. The Charles Schwabs, the Merrill Lynches and the Vanguards of the world built their businesses and their brands off the backs of the baby boomers. I think you're gonna see the same thing, storied franchises and huge brands built and growing with the millennials and Gen Z over the next decades to come.
Benjamin Pimentel ( @benpimentel) covers fintech from San Francisco. He has reported on many of the biggest tech stories over the past 20 years for the San Francisco Chronicle, Dow Jones MarketWatch and Business Insider, from the dot-com crash, the rise of cloud computing, social networking and AI to the impact of the Great Recession and the COVID crisis on Silicon Valley and beyond. He can be reached at email@example.com or via Signal at (510)731-8429.