Bulletins

FTC issues stern warning: Biased AI may break the law

FTC issues stern warning: Biased AI may break the law

Acting FTC chair Rebecca Slaughter.

Photo: David Becker/Getty Images

In a blog post this week, the Federal Trade Commission signaled that it's taking a hard look at bias in AI, warning businesses that selling or using such systems could constitute a violation of federal law.


"The FTC Act prohibits unfair or deceptive practices," the post reads. "That would include the sale or use of – for example – racially biased algorithms."

The post also notes that biased AI can violate the Fair Credit Reporting Act and the Equal Credit Opportunity Act. "The FCRA comes into play in certain circumstances where an algorithm is used to deny people employment, housing, credit, insurance, or other benefits," it says. "The ECOA makes it illegal for a company to use a biased algorithm that results in credit discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, national origin, sex, marital status, age, or because a person receives public assistance."

The post mirrors comments made by acting FTC chair Rebecca Slaughter, who recently told Protocol of her intention to ensure that FTC enforcement efforts "continue and sharpen in our long, arduous and very large national task of being anti-racist."

"For me, algorithmic bias is an economic justice issue. We see disparate outcomes coming out of algorithmic decision-making that disproportionately affect and harm Black and brown communities and affect their ability to participate equally in society," Slaughter said at the time. "That's something we need to address, and we need to think about whether it fits under our unfairness framework, whether we might have rule-making authority that could apply to it or whether we use statutes like the Equal Credit Opportunity Act or the Fair Credit Reporting Act."

In the blog post, the FTC urges businesses to test their algorithms for bias, to base their systems on datasets that aren't missing key demographics and to avoid exaggerating what those systems can do, among other things. On Twitter, University of Washington School of Law professor Ryan Calo called the post a "shot across the bow."

"I see this blog post as a signaling a shift in the way the FTC thinks about enforcing the FTC Act in the context of emerging technology," Calo, who co-directs the UW Tech Policy Lab, tweeted. "The concreteness of the examples coupled with repeated references to statutory authority is uncommon."

Indeed, the post concludes with a clear-eyed message to businesses. "Hold yourself accountable," it reads, "or be ready for the FTC to do it for you."

Latest Bulletins

Robinhood missed earning expectations on a 78% drop in crypto trading revenue, and shares dropped after hours.

Keep Reading Show less

Stripe and Klarna are taking on demand for "buy now, pay later" services together through a new partnership deal.

Keep Reading Show less

Facebook has gone through the wringer in recent weeks. Luckily Mark Zuckerberg sees a billion-dollar opportunity at the end of the tunnel: digital clothes in the metaverse.

Keep Reading Show less

A consortium of blockchain companies, NFT gaming firms and the nonprofit Fight for the Future are calling on Valve to reverse its blockchain ban in an open letter published Tuesday.

Keep Reading Show less

Executives from Snap and TikTok testified for the first time before Congress on Tuesday during a hearing on keeping kids safe online. As part of the hearing, both companies, as well as YouTube, agreed to share internal research with Congress about their platforms' impact on kids.

Keep Reading Show less

President Joe Biden has nominated Jessica Rosenworcel, the acting chair of the Federal Communications Commission, to serve as the official head of the agency, and former FCC official Gigi Sohn for the open commission slot, the White House announced Tuesday.

Keep Reading Show less

Amazon is the latest company to set its sights on the live audio market, following in the footsteps of last year's breakout startup Clubhouse. The new product is a multi-platform app known right now as "Project Mic," according to a new report from The Verge.

Keep Reading Show less

Facebook expects to spend more than $10 billion on AR, VR and related hardware as well as the development of metaverse apps and services this year. CEO Mark Zuckerberg told investors during the company's Q3 earnings call Monday that the company will ramp up investment in the area, and warned that it won't see a return on that investment any time soon.

Keep Reading Show less

Jeff Bezos' Blue Origin wants to build a private space station in low-earth orbit in the next decade, intended for research, commerce, space tourism or as a leasable "address for orbit."

Keep Reading Show less

Tesla became a $1 trillion company Monday when its share price soared above $1000, ending at $1,024 when the market closed Monday.

Keep Reading Show less

The State Department has decided to create a bureau of cyberspace and digital policy, as well as a new point person or group for issues of emerging or critical technologies, in order to address international concerns with hacking, ransomware and internet freedom, according to a Wall Street Journal report.

Keep Reading Show less

Spotify, Dell and SAP topped this year's "America's Most Loved Workplaces" rankings from Newsweek.

The first-ever rankings from Newsweek took into account several criteria for inclusion for the 100 companies that made the cut, including collaboration and teamwork, opportunities for advancement, doing good and a "practice-what-you-preach" culture, as well as how employees feel about the organization.

Keep Reading Show less

Global memory prices may rise after a magnitude 6.2 earthquake struck early Sunday in Taiwan and impacted production at a Micron Technology facility responsible for nearly 10% of the world's memory supply.

Keep Reading Show less

Faze Clan, the gaming company known best for its roster of social media personalities and esports teams, is going public through a SPAC merger next year in a deal valuing the company at $1 billion.

Keep Reading Show less

Mastercard providers will be able to issue crypto debit and credit cards and offer crypto rewards thanks to a new partnership with digital assets exchange Bakkt announced today.

Keep Reading Show less

Guessing poor passwords and basic email phishing attacks really seem to work, according to a report out from Microsoft today that the Russian hackers behind the SolarWinds attack have been using this basic technique to successfully breach as many as 14 U.S.-based companies.

Keep Reading Show less

A Twitter account promoting the Shiba Inu cryptocurrency did not get what it was hoping for when it asked Elon Musk how much $Shib he owns. "None," was Musk's one-word response.

Keep Reading Show less

Hertz has purchased 100,000 Tesla vehicles for its rental offerings in the U.S. and in parts of Europe, as the company pushes to try to electrify its fleet of rental cars, the company announced today.

Keep Reading Show less

Responding to rumors from last week, PayPal said Sunday that it was "not pursuing an acquisition of Pinterest at this time."

Keep Reading Show less

Adobe said it will place employees on unpaid leave if they're not vaccinated by Dec. 8, CNBC reported Friday. The company cited President Joe Biden's executive order on vaccines as rationale for the new rule, according to a notice the company sent to employees.

Keep Reading Show less

Epic Games will no longer give employees every other Friday off, Bloomberg reported Friday.

Keep Reading Show less

A new Facebook whistleblower is accusing Facebook of prioritizing money over the fight against hate speech and misinformation, The Washington Post reported Friday. The whistleblower, who is a former member of the platform's Integrity team and spoke under the condition of anonymity to The Post, made those claims to the SEC as well.

Keep Reading Show less

Walmart will now let customers buy bitcoin. And it's not a hoax this time.

Keep Reading Show less

Snap shares fell around 22% as the market opened Friday morning, the day after Snap announcing Apple's ad-tracking changes is presenting more of a challenge than it thought. "We grappled with industry changes to the way advertising is targeted, optimized, and measured on iOS that created a more significant impact on our business than we had expected," Snap's Chief Business Officer Jeremi Gorman said on the company's earnings call Thursday.

Keep Reading Show less

Lyft users reported over 4,000 instances of sexual assault between 2017 and 2019, according to the ride-hailing app's first community safety report released Thursday. The report comes two years after Uber released a similar report on its own platform.

Keep Reading Show less