Protocol | China

Chinese-language indie media has its NFT moment

"Finally there is a new wave we can catch. The previous technological changes were squeezing us out."

Image of a curved "wailing wall" NFT made of white text on a black background.

The freewheeling NFT technology has inspired several forward-looking publications and platforms to explore ways to secure high quality Chinese-language news content and help content creators who struggle to profit from their work.

Image: Initium Media

The NFT has already shaken up the art world; if China is any indication, the news media could be next. In the U.S. mainstream giants like The New York Times and CNN have cautiously entered the newest crypto gold rush. But in Greater China, it's the small, vulnerable independent Chinese-language media on the bleeding edge. And they are hoping their attempts to adopt new technology to weather financial and political turbulence can inspire the West.

In early September, Initium Media, a reputable independent Chinese-language news site specializing in deep coverage of politics, society and culture in Hong Kong, Taiwan and China, became the first Chinese-language outlet to sell its NFTs. Matters, a decentralized Chinese-language publishing platform based on blockchain technology, has several plans in the works to transition itself to a blockchain-based SaaS platform that provides tech tools to help Chinese publications, publishers and content creators, including Initium Media, to thrive through creating and trading NFTs. is known for hosting cyber refugees, from those who don't feel free to write or speak on mainland China's web to those staying away from Facebook's algorithms.

An NFT represents a collectible asset — digital or non digital — encoded with a unique identifier that proves its authenticity and its ownership. It lives on a blockchain, a digital decentralized ledger that also records the provenance of Bitcoin, Ethereum and other cryptocurrencies. NFTs can be sold and traded but cannot be erased or altered.

NFT technology has inspired several publications and platforms to explore ways to maximize the value of quality Chinese-language news content that's prone to censorship and help creators who struggle to profit from their work. In a way, the imminent threat of government censorship has forced beleaguered independent Chinese-language news and content sites to lean on decentralized technologies more than peers abroad.

"[Turning to NFT] is self-help for all independent creators and independent media," said Zhang Jieping, founder and CEO of Matters,news and a veteran journalist with roots in mainland China, Hong Kong and Taiwan.

An early NFT triumph

Earlier this year, inspired by the American digital artist Beeple, who sold his NFT for a whopping $69.3 million, the Singapore-based Initium started to explore auctioning NFTs.

On Sept. 8, Initium Media released its first NFT project, The Erased. The project is comprised of three collectable interactive media works based on public events that significantly impacted mainland Chinese and Hong Kong residents in the past three years. One NFT visualizes China's "wailing wall," which contains over 730,000 messages Chinese web users left under the COVID-19 whistleblowing doctor Li Wenliang's Weibo post after his passing. Another NFT, titled Uprooted, is a first-person narration by a migrant worker among the many evicted by the Beijing municipal government in the winter of 2017. (The government famously called this group of victims a "low-end population.") The third NFT, The Disappeared Hong Kong Media, visualizes the political challenges Hong Kong faces following the passing of Hong Kong's National Security Law. It enumerates the media outlets that have faced censorship, shut down orders, lawsuits and mass resignations over the past two years.

"We hope to share these memories with you, to resist forgetting, resist being removed, and resist attempts to rewrite history," Initium Media wrote in a statement on OpenSea, a major NFT marketplace.

Initium executive editor Susie Wu told Protocol that to her surprise, all seven copies of the news site's first three NFTs sold out immediately. One copy of The Disappeared Hong Kong Media sold within eight minutes of listing. The highly anticipated and most valuable NFT, the Wailing Wall, was auctioned off for 1 ETH, which equaled $3,616 as of this writing. All told, Initium has booked 4 ETH (over $14,000) in sales from its three NFTs, an equivalent of annual membership fees paid by over 200 subscribers.

The six-year-old Initium had just broken even in August, supported primarily by 60,000 subscribing members. Its NFT sales number might be nothing for a major global news outlet, but for a small independent Chinese-language publication squeezed by both governmental censorship in China and dominating social media platforms ranging from Facebook to TikTok, the possibility of adding a stream of revenue through NFTs is significant.

"It's not that if we can sell NFTs, then we can survive," Wu said. "But the initial sales are indeed exciting news because finally there is a new wave we are able to catch. After all, the previous technological changes, like short videos, are squeezing us out."

NFT as a service

Zhang, the founder of, told Protocol that in November her platform is launching a project that will allow Matters users to trade NFT avatars and access Matter's own tools, which will empower users to independently open censorship-resilient sites, turning their work into a part of the Ethereum blockchain as a public ledger and selling it.

After a new NFT is sold, the next owner of the NFT can then add content, leaving their personal mark on the collectible. By trading avatars, the value of the NFT increases, and Matters Lab can take commissions from each NFT trading. Going forward, plans also to allow independent journalists to raise funds for projects through NFTs, which can be owned by multiple NFT buyers.

"We will allow creators to secure full ownership of their work, but we also hope to create a healthy community open for other individuals and media to engage with quality content," Liu Guo,' co-founder and CTO, told Protocol. "We are starting this effort in the Chinese-language world, and it can be applied to the English world."

Liu believes that Chinese independent media's NFT experiments can ultimately offer lessons and toolkits for English-language media, which do not face the same looming danger of being wiped out or co-opted by the government.

"I think decentralized technologies will benefit creators all over the world. It's just that independent Chinese creators are in a bigger crisis because of governmental censorship, so we are incentivized to use decentralized technologies to resist centralized power," Liu said. "But censorship exists in the West, too. Capital can be a powerful but invisible censoring force. We are thinking of solutions to resist censorship before everyone else in the English world realizes the threat is real."

Protocol | Workplace

The whiteboard wars: Miro and Figma want to make meetings better

Miro and Figma separately launched features on Tuesday aimed at improving collaboration on their platforms.

Whiteboard rivals Miro and Figma each released collaboration improvements.

Logos: Figma and Miro

We expect a lot from our productivity tools these days. You can't just stroll over to your team members' desks and show them what you're working on anymore. Most of those interactions need to happen online, and it's even better if the work and the communication can happen in one place. Miro and Figma — competitors in the collaborative whiteboard space — understand how critical remote collaboration is, and are both working to up their meeting game.

This week, both platforms announced features aimed at improving the collaboration experience, each vying to be the home base for teams to work and hang out together. Figma announced updates to its multiplayer whiteboard FigJam, and Miro announced a new set of tools that it's calling Miro Smart Meetings. Figma's goal is to make FigJam more customizable and accessible for everyone; Miro wants to be the best place for content-centered, professional meetings. They both want to be the go-to hub for teams looking to get stuff done.

Keep Reading Show less
Lizzy Lawrence

Lizzy Lawrence ( @LizzyLaw_) is a reporter at Protocol, covering tools and productivity in the workplace. She's a recent graduate of the University of Michigan, where she studied sociology and international studies. She served as editor in chief of The Michigan Daily, her school's independent newspaper. She's based in D.C., and can be reached at

The way we work has fundamentally changed. COVID-19 upended business dealings and office work processes, putting into hyperdrive a move towards digital collaboration platforms that allow teams to streamline processes and communicate from anywhere. According to the International Data Corporation, the revenue for worldwide collaboration applications increased 32.9 percent from 2019 to 2020, reaching $22.6 billion; it's expected to become a $50.7 billion industry by 2025.

"While consumers and early adopter businesses had widely embraced collaborative applications prior to the pandemic, the market saw five years' worth of new users in the first six months of 2020," said Wayne Kurtzman, research director of social and collaboration at IDC. "This has cemented collaboration, at least to some extent, for every business, large and small."

Keep Reading Show less
Kate Silver

Kate Silver is an award-winning reporter and editor with 15-plus years of journalism experience. Based in Chicago, she specializes in feature and business reporting. Kate's reporting has appeared in the Washington Post, The Chicago Tribune, The Atlantic's CityLab, Atlas Obscura, The Telegraph and many other outlets.

Protocol | Workplace

Hybrid work is here to stay. Here’s how to do it better.

We've recovered from the COVID-19 digital collaboration whiplash. Now we must build a more intentional model for hybrid work.

This is a call to managers to understand the mundane or unwanted projects their employees face, and what work excites them.

Photo: Adobe

Ashley Still is Adobe's Senior Vice President of Digital Media – Marketing, Strategy & Global Partnerships.

When COVID-19 hit, we were forced into a fully digital mode of business operation. Overnight, we adopted available remote work tools — even if imperfect, they were the best tools for the job.

Keep Reading Show less
Ashley Still
As Senior Vice President, Digital Media – Marketing, Strategy & Global Partnerships, Ashley Still leads product marketing and business development for Adobe's flagship Creative Cloud and Document Cloud offerings. This includes iconic software brands such as Photoshop, Lightroom, Illustrator, InDesign and Acrobat. Her expanded remit now includes Adobe's strategic partnership work with technology companies globally, including Apple, Microsoft and Google; and driving Adobe's fast-growing mobile app business. Her team is also responsible for the demand generation marketing campaigns that makes Adobe the market-leader, across creative and document productivity segments. Previously she was Vice President and General Manager, Adobe Creative Cloud for Enterprise. Here her team delivered an integrated content creation, collaboration and publishing solution that securely enables brands to create exceptional design and content. Prior to this, Ashley was Senior Director of Product & Marketing for Adobe Primetime, an Internet television platform used by Comcast, Turner, NBC Sports and other global media companies to deliver TV content and dynamic advertising to any Internet device. Under Ashley's leadership, Adobe Primetime won an Emmy Award for the Adobe Pass TV-Everywhere service. Ashley joined Adobe in 2004 following her internship with the company and held several product management positions for Adobe Photoshop. Still earned her Bachelor of Arts degree from Yale University and her Masters degree from Stanford Graduate School of Business.
Protocol | Workplace

Meet the productivity app influencers

Within the realm of productivity influencing, there is a somewhat surprising sect: Creators who center their content around a specific productivity app.

People are making content and building courses based off of their favorite productivity apps.

Photos: Courtesy

This is the creators' internet. The rest of us are just living in it. We're accustomed to the scores of comedy TikTokers, beauty YouTubers and lifestyle Instagram influencers gracing our feeds. A significant portion of these creators are productivity gurus, advising their followers on how they organize their lives.

Within the realm of productivity influencing, there's a surprising sect: Creators who center their content around a specific productivity app. They're a powerful part of these apps' ecosystems, drawing users to the platform and offering helpful tips and tricks. Notion in particular has a huge influencer family, with #notion gaining millions of views on TikTok.

Keep Reading Show less
Lizzy Lawrence

Lizzy Lawrence ( @LizzyLaw_) is a reporter at Protocol, covering tools and productivity in the workplace. She's a recent graduate of the University of Michigan, where she studied sociology and international studies. She served as editor in chief of The Michigan Daily, her school's independent newspaper. She's based in D.C., and can be reached at

Payments Infrastructure

Power Index: Payments Infrastructure

A data-driven ranking of the most powerful players in tech — and the challengers best positioned to disrupt them.

Welcome back to the Protocol Power Index, a ranking of the most powerful companies by tech industry subsector, as well as the companies best positioned to challenge them. This time: payments infrastructure.

The payments stack has been evolving dramatically in the last decade with the rise of ecommerce and new forms of money transfers, and though it's a sector that's been touched by Midas through each of its iterations, there's somehow still space for newcomers to be minted. Payments giants have ceded coveted territory to new market entrants during the process, but they are hardly down for the count.

Keep Reading Show less
Hirsh Chitkara
Hirsh Chitkara (@ChitkaraHirsh) is a researcher at Protocol, based out of New York City. Before joining Protocol, he worked for Business Insider Intelligence, where he wrote about Big Tech, telecoms, workplace privacy, smart cities, and geopolitics. He also worked on the Strategy & Analytics team at the Cleveland Indians.
Latest Stories