Clarence Thomas wants to check Big Tech. Texas could be his shot.

Thomas has argued social media companies are like common carriers. Texas’s social media law, which could make its way to SCOTUS, makes a similar case.

Justice Clarence Thomas.

Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas has been itching for a case that could rein in Section 230.

Photographer: Al Drago/Bloomberg via Getty Images

For years, Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas has been openly itching for a case that would give the court an opportunity to rein in Section 230 protections. Now, Texas’ controversial social media “censorship” law could give him an opening.

The Texas law prohibits tech platforms with more than 50 million monthly users from moderating content on the basis of “viewpoint,” an ill-defined concept that is ripe for bad-faith interpretation. On Wednesday, a Fifth Circuit appeals court lifted an injunction on the law, which will now take effect in the state.

Tech giants including Meta, Google, Snap, Twitter, TikTok and others are now scrambling for a legal remedy. None of those companies would share information with Protocol about what happens next. In all likelihood, they’re still figuring it out themselves.

One option on the table, though, would be for the plaintiffs in the case — industry groups NetChoice and the Computer and Communications Industry Association — to try their luck with the Supreme Court. In a statement, CCIA president Matt Schruers said, “No option is off the table.”

For Thomas, at least, such a case might be welcome. He’s argued in the past that tech platforms are "sufficiently akin" to common carriers and that the court will soon have no choice but to “address how our legal doctrines apply to highly concentrated, privately owned information infrastructure such as digital platforms." Thomas’s public turn against tech came shortly after he hired a clerk who was previously a lawyer for noted Sec. 230 critic Sen. Josh Hawley.

"He took the opportunity to rip on Sec. 230 in [a] case that didn’t even present the issue in any way at all. So one that presents the issue, I think he’ll certainly jump on that,” said David Greene, senior staff attorney at the Electronic Frontier Foundation.

It’s possible the Supreme Court could take up the case on its shadow docket, without hearing oral arguments — an outcome University of Texas at Austin law professor Steve Vladeck, who is writing a book on the shadow docket, believes is likely. “I just don’t see how social media companies can risk having this law stay on the books,” Vladeck said. “There will be a ton of pressure to ask the Supreme Court to vacate the stay.” Vladeck pointed to a similar shadow docket decision in March when the Court overturned the Fifth Circuit’s block on the Biden administration’s military vaccine mandate.

Not everyone shares Vladeck’s certainty. According to Corbin Barthold, internet policy counsel for the think tank TechFreedom, “it is still extraordinarily rare for the Supreme Court to review any aspect of an appeal before that appeal is complete.” While the Fifth Circuit lifted the injunction on the Texas law, suggesting it’s likely to uphold the law on appeal, the appeal itself is still pending.

But, Vladeck said, while this has been the case historically, the Supreme Court has become much more active in intervening, particularly in cases that are likely to cause a huge disruption, like this one. “The reality here is that the Fifth Circuit stay is going to create such an immediate impact that it’s going to be hard for the court to think that it's appropriate to wait,” Vladeck said.

Even if the case doesn’t make it to the shadow docket, though, it could still wind its way to the Supreme Court; it’ll just take longer. While NetChoice and CCIA fight it out in the Fifth Circuit, the 11th Circuit is also considering a similar social media law in Florida, and Barthold expects that court to be more deliberate in its decision than the Fifth Circuit was. Being more deliberate than the Fifth Circuit, incidentally, won’t be much of a challenge: The court lifted the injunction on the Texas law just two days after hearing oral arguments, without so much as an opinion. During the arguments, the judges seemed perplexed about whether Twitter is even a website. “To just issue an order like this with no opinion on such an unprecedented law,” Barthold said, “it had a flavor of spite to it.”

If the 11th and Fifth Circuits split, the Supreme Court might take up the case the old-fashioned way, with oral arguments and all. “Then I would flip my whole analysis and say it is likely, even probable, that the Supreme Court would hear that case,” he said.

The question then is, would Thomas’ fellow conservative justices see things the same way he does? That answer is still very unknown. So far, everything Thomas has written on Sec. 230 has only had his name attached.

If history serves, his conservative colleagues would be a hard sell. In 2019, all of the conservative justices, including Thomas, joined Justice Brett Kavanaugh in a decision that found public-access channels can’t violate people’s constitutional rights because, though they provide a public forum for speech, they are not themselves state actors. That makes them seem unlikely candidates to rally behind the Texas law, which would also effectively turn tech platforms into common carriers.

One thing is certain, though. If the Supreme Court were to take up the case in this way, it would take time, maybe even years. In the meantime, tech platforms would have to find a way to live with the Texas law as it is — or die trying.

With additional reporting by Ben Brody.


Election markets are far from a sure bet

Kalshi has big-name backing for its plan to offer futures contracts tied to election results. Will that win over a long-skeptical regulator?

Whether Kalshi’s election contracts could be considered gaming or whether they serve a true risk-hedging purpose is one of the top questions the CFTC is weighing in its review.

Photo illustration: Getty Images; Protocol

Crypto isn’t the only emerging issue on the CFTC’s plate. The futures regulator is also weighing a fintech sector that has similarly tricky political implications: election bets.

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission has set Oct. 28 as a date by which it hopes to decide whether the New York-based startup Kalshi can offer a form of wagering up to $25,000 on which party will control the House of Representatives and Senate after the midterms. PredictIt, another online market for election trading, has also sued the regulator over its decision to cancel a no-action letter.

Keep Reading Show less
Ryan Deffenbaugh
Ryan Deffenbaugh is a reporter at Protocol focused on fintech. Before joining Protocol, he reported on New York's technology industry for Crain's New York Business. He is based in New York and can be reached at rdeffenbaugh@protocol.com.
Sponsored Content

Great products are built on strong patents

Experts say robust intellectual property protection is essential to ensure the long-term R&D required to innovate and maintain America's technology leadership.

Every great tech product that you rely on each day, from the smartphone in your pocket to your music streaming service and navigational system in the car, shares one important thing: part of its innovative design is protected by intellectual property (IP) laws.

From 5G to artificial intelligence, IP protection offers a powerful incentive for researchers to create ground-breaking products, and governmental leaders say its protection is an essential part of maintaining US technology leadership. To quote Secretary of Commerce Gina Raimondo: "intellectual property protection is vital for American innovation and entrepreneurship.”

Keep Reading Show less
James Daly
James Daly has a deep knowledge of creating brand voice identity, including understanding various audiences and targeting messaging accordingly. He enjoys commissioning, editing, writing, and business development, particularly in launching new ventures and building passionate audiences. Daly has led teams large and small to multiple awards and quantifiable success through a strategy built on teamwork, passion, fact-checking, intelligence, analytics, and audience growth while meeting budget goals and production deadlines in fast-paced environments. Daly is the Editorial Director of 2030 Media and a contributor at Wired.

The Uber verdict shows why mandatory disclosure isn't such a bad idea

The conviction of Uber's former chief security officer, Joe Sullivan, seems likely to change some minds in the debate over proposed cyber incident reporting regulations.

Executives and boards will now be "a whole lot less likely to cover things up," said one information security veteran.

Photo: Al Drago/Bloomberg via Getty Images

If nothing else, the guilty verdict delivered Wednesday in a case involving Uber's former security head will have this effect on how breaches are handled in the future: Executives and boards, according to information security veteran Michael Hamilton, will be "a whole lot less likely to cover things up."

Following the conviction of former Uber chief security officer Joe Sullivan, "we likely will get better voluntary reporting" of cyber incidents, said Hamilton, formerly the chief information security officer of the City of Seattle, and currently the founder and CISO at cybersecurity vendor Critical Insight.

Keep Reading Show less
Kyle Alspach

Kyle Alspach ( @KyleAlspach) is a senior reporter at Protocol, focused on cybersecurity. He has covered the tech industry since 2010 for outlets including VentureBeat, CRN and the Boston Globe. He lives in Portland, Oregon, and can be reached at kalspach@protocol.com.


Delta and MIT are running flight tests to fix contrails

The research team and airline are running flight tests to determine if it’s possible to avoid the climate-warming effects of contrails.

Delta and MIT just announced a partnership to test how to mitigate persistent contrails.

Photo: Gabriela Natiello/Unsplash

Contrails could be responsible for up to 2% of all global warming, and yet how they’re formed and how to mitigate them is barely understood by major airlines.

That may be changing.

Keep Reading Show less
Michelle Ma

Michelle Ma (@himichellema) is a reporter at Protocol covering climate. Previously, she was a news editor of live journalism and special coverage for The Wall Street Journal. Prior to that, she worked as a staff writer at Wirecutter. She can be reached at mma@protocol.com.


Inside Amazon’s free video strategy

Amazon has been doubling down on original content for Freevee, its ad-supported video service, which has seen a lot of growth thanks to a deep integration with other Amazon properties.

Freevee’s investment into original programming like 'Bosch: Legacy' has increased by 70%.

Photo: Tyler Golden/Amazon Freevee

Amazon’s streaming efforts have long been all about Prime Video. So the company caught pundits by surprise when, in early 2019, it launched a stand-alone ad-supported streaming service called IMDb Freedive, with Techcrunch calling the move “a bit odd.”

Nearly four years and two rebrandings later, Amazon’s ad-supported video efforts appear to be flourishing. Viewership of the service grew by 138% from 2020 to 2021, according to Amazon. The company declined to share any updated performance data on the service, which is now called Freevee, but a spokesperson told Protocol the performance of originals in particular “exceeded expectations,” leading Amazon to increase investments into original content by 70% year-over-year.

Keep Reading Show less
Janko Roettgers

Janko Roettgers (@jank0) is a senior reporter at Protocol, reporting on the shifting power dynamics between tech, media, and entertainment, including the impact of new technologies. Previously, Janko was Variety's first-ever technology writer in San Francisco, where he covered big tech and emerging technologies. He has reported for Gigaom, Frankfurter Rundschau, Berliner Zeitung, and ORF, among others. He has written three books on consumer cord-cutting and online music and co-edited an anthology on internet subcultures. He lives with his family in Oakland.

Latest Stories