Elizabeth Holmes' lies were 'callous' and 'criminal,' the prosecution says

The government concluded months of testimony with an argument that Holmes made the deliberate choice to lie to investors and patients about her blood-testing startup’s difficulties.

Elizabeth Holmes

Elizabeth Holmes faces 11 counts of wire fraud and conspiracy to commit fraud against both investors and patients.

Photo: David Paul Morris/Bloomberg via Getty Images

Elizabeth Holmes had a choice.

That’s what Assistant U.S. Attorney Jeff Schenk argued in a federal courthouse in San Jose Thursday as the government’s fraud case against the former Theranos CEO drew to a close.

In closing arguments, Schenk said Holmes could have pitched investors the honest truth about Theranos: that it was never validated by pharmaceutical companies. That its devices were never used in medevacs or on the battlefield in Afghanistan. That its relationship with Walgreens was not healthy. That Theranos’ technology could only do a handful of tests after 10 years. That Theranos used modified third-party devices for most of its tests.

If she’d told patients the truth, Holmes would have had to admit that the tests that Theranos ran on its own devices often failed quality control checks, the prosecution argued. That it often took a venous draw, rather than a finger prick stick with a few drops, to get the blood.

Instead, the government claimed, Holmes made a choice to lie to investors and patients, a decision that was “not only callous, but also criminal,” Schenk told the jury.

The prosecution’s swan song capped testimony from 29 witnesses spanning four months. Holmes faces 11 counts of wire fraud and conspiracy to commit fraud against both investors and patients.

The government’s arguments focused on the idea that Holmes knew there were problems at the company and chose not to disclose them. Instead, Holmes’ role in the “scheme,” as the government alleges, was to keep the company alive by seeking infusions of funds, whether that was by attracting paying patients or continuing to recruit new investors.

Much of Holmes’ defense has been to point the finger at former Theranos COO Sunny Balwani, a trusted adviser and her long-term boyfriend who she says misled her. But the prosecution argued that the two worked in concert in a scheme to defraud.

Holmes’ role was to recruit investors and deliver false statements to them, whether it was directly through investor presentation or using articles in the media, like a Fortune magazine cover, Schenk said. Balwani’s alleged role was to run the lab and help deliver the investor presentations and false statements. These weren’t siloed responsibilities, the government contended, as it sought to show Holmes and Balwani keeping each other in the loop, often forwarding emails to each other when problems arose and deciding how to respond together.

Some moves were also entirely Holmes'. She admitted that she had added Pfizer’s logo to a report prepared by Theranos about their technology for the pharmaceutical company, and she did a similar move for a report featuring a Schering-Plough logo. When she sent the reports to Walgreens, she characterized them as “independent due diligence reports.”

The prosecution also replayed several audio clips to show that it was Holmes, and not Balwani, who tried to mislead the public. For example, in an interview, Fortune reporter Roger Parloff repeatedly asked why some patients would have had to do a venous blood draw instead of a finger prick at the Walgreens testing locations. Holmes’ excuse was that it was a scaling issue, or a problem of success — that Theranos had too many blood draws coming in so it was more efficient to collect using one larger container. The reality inside the lab was that Theranos could only run a handful of tests using the finger prick samples, Schenk said.

When it came to misleading patients, the government argued that the company’s advertising promising “faster,” “cheaper” and “more accurate” results was misleading, particularly around the issues of accuracy. Whistleblower Erika Cheung had described some of the quality control tests as “flipping a coin” on whether or not it would work. Theranos’ former lab director Adam Rosendorff had testified that the company “valued PR and fundraising over patient care” and that he’d raised concerns before the company launched in Walgreens.

The government also spent time trying to rebut arguments from the defense. On Holmes’ inexperience — she dropped out from Stanford to start Theranos — Schenk pointed out she had been running Theranos for nearly a decade and was closer to 30. And on the idea that many startups fail and failure is not a crime, he argued that Holmes lied because she didn’t want it to fail.

Schenk also praised witnesses who acted as whistleblowers, reporting Theranos’ actions to regulators and reporters like the Wall Street Journal’s John Carreyrou.

“The story of Theranos is in some ways a tragedy, but it is also a story of some people acting with remarkable integrity,” Schenk said, highlighting how employees like Cheung and Rosendorff spoke out.

One of the original Theranos whistleblowers, Tyler Shultz, watched the proceedings from the overflow room Thursday.


Apple's new payments tech won't kill Square

It could be used in place of the Square dongle, but it's far short of a full-fledged payments service.

The Apple system would reportedly only handle contactless payments.

Photo: Nathan Dumlao/Unsplash

Apple is preparing a product to enable merchants to accept contactless payments via iPhones without additional hardware, according to Bloomberg.

While this may seem like a move to compete with Block and its Square merchant unit in point-of-sale payments, that’s unlikely. The Apple service is using technology from its acquisition of Mobeewave in 2020 that enables contactless payments using NFC technology.

Keep Reading Show less
Tomio Geron

Tomio Geron ( @tomiogeron) is a San Francisco-based reporter covering fintech. He was previously a reporter and editor at The Wall Street Journal, covering venture capital and startups. Before that, he worked as a staff writer at Forbes, covering social media and venture capital, and also edited the Midas List of top tech investors. He has also worked at newspapers covering crime, courts, health and other topics. He can be reached at tgeron@protocol.com or tgeron@protonmail.com.

Sponsored Content

A CCO’s viewpoint on top enterprise priorities in 2022

The 2022 non-predictions guide to what your enterprise is working on starting this week

As Honeywell’s global chief commercial officer, I am privileged to have the vantage point of seeing the demands, challenges and dynamics that customers across the many sectors we cater to are experiencing and sharing.

This past year has brought upon all businesses and enterprises an unparalleled change and challenge. This was the case at Honeywell, for example, a company with a legacy in innovation and technology for over a century. When I joined the company just months before the pandemic hit we were already in the midst of an intense transformation under the leadership of CEO Darius Adamczyk. This transformation spanned our portfolio and business units. We were already actively working on products and solutions in advanced phases of rollouts that the world has shown a need and demand for pre-pandemic. Those included solutions in edge intelligence, remote operations, quantum computing, warehouse automation, building technologies, safety and health monitoring and of course ESG and climate tech which was based on our exceptional success over the previous decade.

Keep Reading Show less
Jeff Kimbell
Jeff Kimbell is Senior Vice President and Chief Commercial Officer at Honeywell. In this role, he has broad responsibilities to drive organic growth by enhancing global sales and marketing capabilities. Jeff has nearly three decades of leadership experience. Prior to joining Honeywell in 2019, Jeff served as a Partner in the Transformation Practice at McKinsey & Company, where he worked with companies facing operational and financial challenges and undergoing “good to great” transformations. Before that, he was an Operating Partner at Silver Lake Partners, a global leader in technology and held a similar position at Cerberus Capital LP. Jeff started his career as a Manufacturing Team Manager and Engineering Project Manager at Procter & Gamble before becoming a strategy consultant at Bain & Company and holding executive roles at Dell EMC and Transamerica Corporation. Jeff earned a B.S. in electrical engineering at Kansas State University and an M.B.A. at Dartmouth College.

Why does China's '996' overtime culture persist?

A Tencent worker’s open criticism shows why this work schedule is hard to change in Chinese tech.

Excessive overtime is one of the plights Chinese workers are grappling with across sectors.

Photo: VCG/VCG via Getty Images

Workers were skeptical when Chinese Big Tech called off its notorious and prevalent overtime policy: “996,” a 12-hour, six-day work schedule. They were right to be: A recent incident at gaming and social media giant Tencent proves that a deep-rooted overtime culture is hard to change, new policy or not.

Defiant Tencent worker Zhang Yifei, who openly challenged the company’s overtime culture, reignited wide discussion of the touchy topic this week. What triggered Zhang's criticism, according to his own account, was his team’s positive attitude toward overtime. His team, which falls under WeCom — a business communication and office collaboration tool similar to Slack — announced its in-house Breakthrough Awards. The judges’ comments to one winner highly praised them for logging “over 20 hours of intense work nonstop,” to help meet the deadline for launching a marketing page.

Keep Reading Show less
Shen Lu

Shen Lu covers China's tech industry.

Boost 2

Can Matt Mullenweg save the internet?

He's turning Automattic into a different kind of tech giant. But can he take on the trillion-dollar walled gardens and give the internet back to the people?

Matt Mullenweg, CEO of Automattic and founder of WordPress, poses for Protocol at his home in Houston, Texas.
Photo: Arturo Olmos for Protocol

In the early days of the pandemic, Matt Mullenweg didn't move to a compound in Hawaii, bug out to a bunker in New Zealand or head to Miami and start shilling for crypto. No, in the early days of the pandemic, Mullenweg bought an RV. He drove it all over the country, bouncing between Houston and San Francisco and Jackson Hole with plenty of stops in national parks. In between, he started doing some tinkering.

The tinkering is a part-time gig: Most of Mullenweg’s time is spent as CEO of Automattic, one of the web’s largest platforms. It’s best known as the company that runs WordPress.com, the hosted version of the blogging platform that powers about 43% of the websites on the internet. Since WordPress is open-source software, no company technically owns it, but Automattic provides tools and services and oversees most of the WordPress-powered internet. It’s also the owner of the booming ecommerce platform WooCommerce, Day One, the analytics tool Parse.ly and the podcast app Pocket Casts. Oh, and Tumblr. And Simplenote. And many others. That makes Mullenweg one of the most powerful CEOs in tech, and one of the most important voices in the debate over the future of the internet.

Keep Reading Show less
David Pierce

David Pierce ( @pierce) is Protocol's editorial director. Prior to joining Protocol, he was a columnist at The Wall Street Journal, a senior writer with Wired, and deputy editor at The Verge. He owns all the phones.


Spoiler alert: We’re already in the beta-metaverse

300 million people use metaverse-like platforms — Fortnite, Roblox and Minecraft — every month. That equals the total user base of the internet in 1999.

A lot of us are using platforms that can be considered metaverse prototypes.

Illustration: Christopher T. Fong/Protocol

What does it take to build the metaverse? What building blocks do we need, how can companies ensure that the metaverse is going to be inclusive, and how do we know that we have arrived in the 'verse?

This week, we convened a panel of experts for Protocol Entertainment’s first virtual live event, including Epic Games Unreal Engine VP and GM Marc Petit, Oasis Consortium co-founder and President Tiffany Xingyu Wang and Emerge co-founder and CEO Sly Lee.

Keep Reading Show less
Janko Roettgers

Janko Roettgers (@jank0) is a senior reporter at Protocol, reporting on the shifting power dynamics between tech, media, and entertainment, including the impact of new technologies. Previously, Janko was Variety's first-ever technology writer in San Francisco, where he covered big tech and emerging technologies. He has reported for Gigaom, Frankfurter Rundschau, Berliner Zeitung, and ORF, among others. He has written three books on consumer cord-cutting and online music and co-edited an anthology on internet subcultures. He lives with his family in Oakland.


Lyin’ AI: OpenAI launches new language model despite toxic tendencies

Research company OpenAI says this year’s language model is less toxic than GPT-3. But the new default, InstructGPT, still has tendencies to make discriminatory comments and generate false information.

The new default, called InstructGPT, still has tendencies to make discriminatory comments and generate false information.

Illustration: Pixabay; Protocol

OpenAI knows its text generators have had their fair share of problems. Now the research company has shifted to a new deep-learning model it says works better to produce “fewer toxic outputs” than GPT-3, its flawed but widely-used system.

Starting Thursday, a new model called InstructGPT will be the default technology served up through OpenAI’s API, which delivers foundational AI into all sorts of chatbots, automatic writing tools and other text-based applications. Consider the new system, which has been in beta testing for the past year, to be a work in progress toward an automatic text generator that OpenAI hopes is closer to what humans actually want.

Keep Reading Show less
Kate Kaye

Kate Kaye is an award-winning multimedia reporter digging deep and telling print, digital and audio stories. She covers AI and data for Protocol. Her reporting on AI and tech ethics issues has been published in OneZero, Fast Company, MIT Technology Review, CityLab, Ad Age and Digiday and heard on NPR. Kate is the creator of RedTailMedia.org and is the author of "Campaign '08: A Turning Point for Digital Media," a book about how the 2008 presidential campaigns used digital media and data.

Latest Stories