Fraud or mistakes? Opening trial arguments debate how much Elizabeth Holmes knew.

"Elizabeth Holmes did not go to work every day intending to lie, cheat and steal," her lawyers argued.

Elizabeth Holmes arriving to court with her defense team.

Holmes has pleaded not guilty to 12 counts of fraud and conspiracy to commit fraud.

Photo: Nick Otto/AFP via Getty Images

To the U.S. government, Elizabeth Holmes is a fraudster bent on lying and cheating to get money for her company while deceiving investors and the public on how little its lab work could actually do.

But Holmes' lawyers argue that she isn't a villainous CEO who purposefully deceived everyone. Rather, she's a young Silicon Valley founder who believed so much in her vision and product that she never sold a share and thought that the company's challenges could eventually be overcome.

"Elizabeth Holmes did not go to work every day intending to lie, cheat and steal," said Lance Wade, Holmes' attorney from Washington D.C.-based firm Williams & Connolly. "The government would have you believe her company, her entire life, is a fraud. That is wrong. That is not true."

The opening arguments, which lasted hours, kicked off the start of the high-profile trial of Theranos founder Holmes, who has pleaded not guilty to 12 counts of fraud and conspiracy to commit wire fraud. Spectators arrived at the courthouse in the middle of the night to claim one of the three dozen seats available in the courtroom to the public. Holmes' partner, Billy Evans, with whom she had a son in July, was in the courtroom in the first row.

"This is a case about fraud, about lying and cheating to get money. It's a crime on Main Street and it's a crime in Silicon Valley," said assistant U.S. attorney Robert Leach in the prosecution's opening statement.

A theme of the opening statement was how often Holmes found herself "out of time and out of money" with her company on the brink barely able to meet payroll. To gain funding and customers, the government argued that Holmes deceived investors and the public in six main categories: the miniLab device, military, pharmaceuticals, financials, the Walgreens rollout and the accuracy of tests. The government claimed, for example, that in one inaccurate test, a pregnant woman changed her medication after a test told her she was no longer pregnant.

The government also argued that Theranos overstated the device's capabilities to the public and to investors, like Walgreens and Safeway. The company had published a press release in 2013 stating that its blood-testing device could run any test on a few drops of blood, despite it still relying largely on commercial machines and vein draws.

The trial is also likely to analyze the media's role and the statements that Holmes made to journalists, which landed her on the cover of magazines like Forbes and Fortune. Leach asserted that Holmes used big magazine profiles as part of her lure to investors and as a way to deceive the public. "Her deceit of reporters was an important way that she executed her fraud," Leach said. (Ultimately, it was a WSJ report based off of Theranos whistleblowers that contributed to the company's downfall.)

The challenge for the government will be proving that Holmes had an intent to deceive investors and the public. Holmes' lawyers instead argued that she was a true believer and dedicated her life to it. Despite having opportunities to sell and make "hundreds of millions," her attorney Wade said that Holmes had never sold a share of her company so she wasn't even financially benefiting from the alleged fraud.

"Elizabeth Holmes worked herself to the bone for 15 years trying to make lab testing cheaper and more accessible. She poured her heart and her soul into that effort. Now in the end, Theranos failed. And Ms. Holmes walked away with nothing," Wade said at the start of the defense's opening remarks. "But failure is not a crime. Trying your hardest and coming up short is not a crime. And by the time this trial is over you will see that the villain that the government just presented is actually a living, breathing human being who did her very best each and every day."

Wade painted Holmes as a passionate Silicon Valley CEO who dropped out of Stanford at 19 to pursue a life-changing idea. Because of her age, he said, she surrounded herself with people who had the experience she lacked. For example, Holmes was not legally allowed to manage the lab because she didn't have qualifications, so she hired other lab directors to be in charge of the testing. As a result, her defense argued, she shouldn't be held accountable for the lab's problems when it was regulated by a lab director.

The other finger was pointed at Theranos COO Sunny Balwani, who is standing trial separately in early 2022. Wade said the board had encouraged her to hire someone with business experience, so she hired Balwani to oversee operations, which included financial modeling and the lab's operations.

Her lawyer tiptoed around Holmes' relationship with Balwani, who is also her ex-boyfriend. Before the trial started, the defense had said in filings that Holmes was a victim of an abusive relationship, and it was viewed as a potential defense for her in the case. (Balwani denies it.) Wade told the jury that they will "hear that trusting and relying on Mr. Balwani as her primary adviser was one of her mistakes" and claimed that Balwani was known for his hard-charging personality and having a temper.

Her defense also countered the narrative that Theranos had misled Walgreens when it didn't use its own machines in its store, but instead said that it was a phased plan all along. The first phase was supposed to use commercial testing machines before using the company's own, Wade said. But instead Theranos focused on the first phase and lost sight of other parts, another mistake the company made, he pointed out.

"Ms. Holmes made mistakes, but mistakes are not criminal," he said.

In the end, it will be up to the jury to decide whether Holmes intentionally and knowingly defrauded both investors and paying patients or is just a startup CEO who believed she could change the world, but made a series of mistakes as she got caught up in her own company's hype.


You need a healthy ‘debate culture’

From their first day, employees at Appian are encouraged to disagree with anyone at the company — including the CEO. Here’s how it works.

Appian co-founder and CEO Matt Calkins wants his employees to disagree with him.

Photo: Appian

Matt Calkins often hears that he’s polite, even deferential. But as CEO of Appian, he tells employees to challenge each other — especially their bosses — early and often.

“I love arguments. I love ideas clashing,” Calkins said. “I regard it as a personal compliment when someone respectfully dissents.”

Keep Reading Show less
Allison Levitsky
Allison Levitsky is a reporter at Protocol covering workplace issues in tech. She previously covered big tech companies and the tech workforce for the Silicon Valley Business Journal. Allison grew up in the Bay Area and graduated from UC Berkeley.

Some of the most astounding tech-enabled advances of the next decade, from cutting-edge medical research to urban traffic control and factory floor optimization, will be enabled by a device often smaller than a thumbnail: the memory chip.

While vast amounts of data are created, stored and processed every moment — by some estimates, 2.5 quintillion bytes daily — the insights in that code are unlocked by the memory chips that hold it and transfer it. “Memory will propel the next 10 years into the most transformative years in human history,” said Sanjay Mehrotra, president and CEO of Micron Technology.

Keep Reading Show less
James Daly
James Daly has a deep knowledge of creating brand voice identity, including understanding various audiences and targeting messaging accordingly. He enjoys commissioning, editing, writing, and business development, particularly in launching new ventures and building passionate audiences. Daly has led teams large and small to multiple awards and quantifiable success through a strategy built on teamwork, passion, fact-checking, intelligence, analytics, and audience growth while meeting budget goals and production deadlines in fast-paced environments. Daly is the Editorial Director of 2030 Media and a contributor at Wired.

Gopuff says it will make it through the fast-delivery slump

Maria Renz on her new role, the state of fast delivery and Gopuff’s goals for the coming year.

Gopuff has raised $4 billion at a $15 billion valuation.

Photo: Gopuff

The fast-delivery boom sent startups soaring during the pandemic, only for them to come crashing down in recent months. But Maria Renz said Gopuff is prepared to get through the slump.

“Gopuff is really well-positioned to weather through those challenges that we expect in the next year or so,” Renz told Protocol. “We're first party, we control elements of our mix, like price, very directly. And again, we have nine years of experience.”

Keep Reading Show less
Sarah Roach

Sarah (Sarahroach_) writes for Source Code at Protocol. She's a recent graduate of The George Washington University, where she studied journalism and criminal justice. She served for two years as editor-in-chief of GW's independent newspaper, The GW Hatchet. Sarah is based in New York, and can be reached at sroach@protocol.com


AT&T CTO: Challenges of the cloud transition are interpersonal

Jeremy Legg sat down with Protocol to discuss the race to 5G, the challenges of the cloud transition and nabbing tech talent.

AT&T CTO Jeremy Legg spoke with Protocol about the company's cloud transition and more.

Photo: AT&T

Jeremy Legg is two months into his role as CTO of AT&T, and he has been tasked with a big mandate: transforming the company into a software-driven business, with 5G and fiber as core growth areas.

This isn’t Legg’s first CTO gig, just his biggest one. He’s an entertainment biz guy who’s now at the center of the much bigger, albeit less glamorous, telecom business. Prior to joining AT&T in 2020, Legg was the CTO of WarnerMedia, where he was the technical architect behind HBO Max.

Keep Reading Show less
Michelle Ma

Michelle Ma (@himichellema) is a reporter at Protocol, where she writes about management, leadership and workplace issues in tech. Previously, she was a news editor of live journalism and special coverage for The Wall Street Journal. Prior to that, she worked as a staff writer at Wirecutter. She can be reached at mma@protocol.com.


How Canva uses Canva

Design tips and tricks from the ultimate Canva pros: Canva employees themselves.

Employees use Canva to build the internal weekly “Canvazine,” product vision decks, team swag and more.

Illustration: Christopher T. Fong/Protocol

Ever wondered how the companies behind your favorite tech use their own products? We’ve told you how Spotify uses Spotify, How Slack uses Slack and how Meta uses its workplace tools. We talked to Canva employees about the creative ways they use the design tool.

The thing about Canva is that it's ridiculously easy to use. Anyone, regardless of skill level, can open up the app and produce a visually appealing presentation, infographic or video. The 10-year-old company has become synonymous with DIY design, serving as the preferred Instagram infographic app for the social justice “girlies.” Still, the app has plenty of overlooked features that Canvanauts (Canva’s word for its employees) use every day.

Keep Reading Show less
Lizzy Lawrence

Lizzy Lawrence ( @LizzyLaw_) is a reporter at Protocol, covering tools and productivity in the workplace. She's a recent graduate of the University of Michigan, where she studied sociology and international studies. She served as editor in chief of The Michigan Daily, her school's independent newspaper. She's based in D.C., and can be reached at llawrence@protocol.com.

Latest Stories