Get access to Protocol
Good morning! This Tuesday, the DOJ blames China for Equifax, Uber and Postmates fail to temporarily block AB 5, and the Vision Fund takes its first official loss.
People Are Talking
The FTC needs an overhaul to take on big tech, Senator Josh Hawley said:
- "Google and Facebook have acquired hundreds of companies in the last two decades, yet the FTC never once intervened to try to block any of these acquisitions."
Amazon wants Trump to testify in its JEDI case, along with other White House officials:
- "The question is whether the President of the United States should be allowed to use the budget of the DoD to pursue his own personal and political ends."
Also, Amazon is already the company politicians want it to be, according to … its global affairs head Jay Carney:
- "When it comes to creating jobs, raising wages, providing benefits and training employees for higher-paying jobs, Amazon is doing many good things — for the economy, and for American workers."
- Carney also had A Big Day on Twitter dealing with criticism of his comments, which Matt Stoller summed up thusly: "That's interesting now pay your taxes."
The case against Theranos' Elizabeth Holmes should be dismissed, her attorney said:
- "The indictment is full of ambiguity and fudging language, the government is inserting these phrases so they can shift their theory as they go along in the trial."
The Big Story
The international conspiracy behind the Equifax hack
It was the hack everyone heard about, leading to the settlement that caused us all to naively try to claim our $125. Equifax remains one of the biggest data breaches ever — and now we know what allegedly happened.
- Attorney General William Barr said at a press conference Monday that the DOJ has identified and indicted four members of China's People's Liberation Army in connection with the hack.
- Barr made clear how extraordinary this was: "We normally don't bring criminal charges against members of another country's military or intelligence services outside the United States … the deliberate indiscriminate theft of the vast amounts of sensitive personal data of civilians as occurred here cannot be countenanced."
Our friends at POLITICO have a good rundown of exactly how the hack worked, if you want more details.
I asked Protocol's security reporter, Adam Janofsky, what he thought of it. Here's what he said:
- The indictment might look like a win for U.S. prosecutors and Equifax — and in some ways it is — but it's important to remember that a lot of the damage done won't be reversed.
- The Chinese military likely has a trove of sensitive information on about half of all Americans, which it can use to spy on government officials or blackmail people who are financially stressed.
- Perhaps even worse, the data could be fed into Chinese artificial intelligence tools to target Americans, Barr said.
Equifax might naturally want everyone to move on: One Equifax employee described the day to me as "drinking from a firehose," but also said that it's "like one of those traumatic experiences we can put behind us."
- But the pressure might not be finished just yet. Senator Mark Warner said in a statement that, "the indictment does not detract from the myriad of vulnerabilities and process deficiencies that we saw in Equifax's systems and response to the hack."
How much time is your business spending thinking about China, or hackers at all? Or, actually, here's my real question: Did anyone reading this email ever get their $125? If so, please send me an email: email@example.com. I want to learn your ways.
A finance app gets its banking wings
Varo Money took a big step to becoming a national, digital-only bank, announcing Monday that it's set to receive the first-ever "de novo national bank charter" for a banking startup. It means the company will soon be able to operate as a full-fledged bank, instead of relying on a partner to handle some services.
This is a key moment for Varo, and for the fintech industry as a whole, Varo CEO Colin Walsh told me.
- He recalled a Bloomberg Law story from late last year saying Varo was "an important bellwether for the fate of fintech banking." If Varo couldn't get approved, there was little hope for anyone else. That's how it felt to him, too.
- Walsh also said he doesn't expect the process to be easier for the long list of other tech companies hoping for a charter — he said that the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation is likely to make everyone jump through the same hoops as Varo did, and many companies simply won't have the expertise or resources.
Varo's been working with regulators since the company's early days in 2016. Walsh says the process hasn't been easy: Varo filed 5,000 pages in applications, had FDIC employees prowling its offices for weeks, and had to build new teams and new systems to satisfy regulatory requirements.
But now Varo, which focuses on lower- and middle-income customers, can offer more to users. "We're not going to open branches, we're not going to open cash vaults, we're not planning to buy an ATM network anytime soon," Walsh said. But it does plan to have a pretty complete product line soon after it becomes an official national bank in the second quarter of this year.
Do you use an app like Varo, Robinhood, or Chime? What would entice you to switch? Let me know: firstname.lastname@example.org.
A MESSAGE FROM NASDAQ
Reimagining Markets Everywhere
Nasdaq Technology is reshaping the future of global markets by redefining what a marketplace can be.
State of the Web
Twitter's up, Yahoo's down, and Google basically owns the web
SimilarWeb published its annual report on the state of the web on Monday, and it's full of interesting tidbits.
First, the not-so-surprising stuff:
- Desktop web browsing is down slightly from last year (and has been decreasing for a while) while mobile traffic continues to climb.
- Google still absolutely dominates the web. Twitter's traffic climbed last year, while Yahoo and Facebook's dropped — though Instagram and WhatsApp both grew significantly.
Then there's the somewhat-surprising stuff:
- Amazon Prime Day has become a top-notch shopping holiday, up there with Black Friday.
- The most mobile-friendly category on the web? Porn. Number two? Gambling. Turns out anything people want to do privately, they do on their phones. Though they pretty much do everything on their phones — the only category still dominated by the desktop is "Arts & Entertainment," which is mostly streaming media.
The report hits on everything from President Trump's continuing reign as the most popular search term on the planet to the remarkable rise of Google Flights and what it means for the online travel business. Flip through this and Benedict Evans' 2020 tech trends, and you'll have 2020 pretty much in focus.
Facebook is hiring a communications manager for its new Oversight Board. Key requirements: lots of experience, good relationships, and (I'm guessing) a remarkable tolerance for chaos.
Eileen Naughton, Google's head of HR, is leaving the company later this year. She's been involved in many of the company's high-profile internal clashes over the last few years.
Amazon's video efforts have a new leader: Mike Hopkins. Previously the chairman of Sony Pictures Television and before that the CEO of Hulu, Hopkins will oversee Prime Video and Amazon Studios.
In Other News
- The White House officially announced its budget proposal for 2021 with a huge increase in AI and quantum spending. Keep in mind that the details will change — a lot — before anything actually passes.
- Amazon is still winning the smart speaker war. A new report found about 70% of people playing music and setting timers and irritatedly shouting "no, I said the LIVING ROOM lights," are doing it with Alexa.
- From Protocol: Uber and Postmates lost their bid for a temporary injunction against AB 5. That means California can enforce the gig-economy law while the fight continues in court.
- The court challenge of the T-Mobile / Sprint merger is coming to a close. The NYT reports that a judge in Manhattan is planning to rule in favor of the deal.
- A Business Insider story caused confusion about Slack. The story implied that IBM had decided to sign up 350,000 employees; Slack's stock spiked on the news, and even paused trading at one point. But in an SEC filing Slack said that IBM has actually been its largest customer for several years — it didn't sign up all 350,000 employees overnight.
- The Bloomberg campaign made a plea to Silicon Valley: send us your best people, and help us win the election.
- From POLITICO: Google is appealing a 2017 antitrust ruling against the company, giving Europe's big-tech fighters their first major public test.
- Bill Gates may not be buying that superyacht after all, the BBC reports. But honestly, he should be. If he's not, get on it. And send me pictures.
- From Protocol: Brandless became the first Vision Fund-backed company to shut down. Biz Carson reports that the company is stopping all orders and laying off nearly 90% of its staff.
One More Thing
When your car-share is a getaway car
One time, I rented a car only to find the windshield had been shattered. Turns out that was nothing: NBC News reports that users of car-sharing services like Getaround and Turo are increasingly finding their cars have been broken into — and even used to commit crimes. Why? Because as NBC puts it, "the app gives precise locations of cars, even for people just browsing without a reservation — and the keys are always left inside." Getaround responded to the story, explaining all the new and existing safety measures it's taking for people's cars.
A MESSAGE FROM NASDAQ
Reimagining Markets Everywhere
Nasdaq Technology is daring to think differently.